Unlike the ever-gossiping Castle, who was practically beaming with schadenfreude, Neal—despite his devastatingly handsome face—looked utterly miserable.
(And seriously, what a waste of that face! In real life, Matt Bomer, the actor who plays Neal, came out as gay. What a tragic loss for womankind!)
Castle, the chaos-loving troublemaker, took immense pleasure in informing Neal that Gianna had specifically brought Kate into Beckett's campaign office not just for her administrative skills, but also to "clear Neal's schedule"—giving him ample time and space to deal with the enthusiastic pursuit of one particular insurance investigator, Sarah Ellis.
Neal's expression soured instantly.
It didn't surprise him that Castle and Gianna knew about this predicament. Years ago, when Neal had first broken out of prison to search for Kate—who had gone off the grid due to being controlled by corrupt FBI agents—he had already witnessed Castle's near-supernatural intelligence network in action.
And now, Castle had an AI system capable of scanning the entire internet for anything that piqued his interest.
So yeah, it wasn't shocking that Castle had found out that Sarah's insurance company was now hot on Neal's trail, demanding the return of the priceless painting he had stolen in Europe.
What was shocking was that Castle—far from offering any kind of help—had instead arranged for Neal's girlfriend to be too busy with Beckett's campaign, leaving him wide open for Sarah's relentless pursuit.
Was this so-called "friend" trying to help him, or just setting him up for prime entertainment?
As Castle's eyes gleamed with curiosity—clearly more interested in the drama than in Neal's suffering—Neal, normally composed and suave, felt the strong urge to punch his so-called best friend in the face.
"So, buddy," Castle pressed eagerly. "Has Sarah tracked you down yet?"
He was completely unfazed by Neal's increasingly murderous glare, instead pushing his luck with that shit-eating grin.
Neal took a deep breath, reminding himself that Castle was just a spectacle-loving bastard—but still a friend.
He was about to speak when—
Bzzzt.
The intercom on his desk buzzed, and his secretary's voice came through.
"Mr. Caffrey, there's a woman named Sarah here to see you. She says she's an investigator for an insurance company. She doesn't have an appointment—should I send her away?"
Neal froze.
Castle's eyes lit up like Christmas morning.
Oh, hell yes. This was going to be good.
Just as Neal opened his mouth to decline the meeting, Castle leaped off the couch—shockingly agile for his not-so-slim frame—and slammed the intercom button before Neal could say a word.
"Send her in! Mr. Caffrey is available now. Please escort her directly to the CEO's office."
Before Neal could even protest, Castle had already cut the call.
He turned back with the smuggest look on his face.
Neal let out a dry laugh, shaking his head.
"You're really that desperate to see some drama?" he asked. "I have a girlfriend, you know. Whatever you're imagining—it's never going to happen."
Castle rolled his eyes. "Oh please, as if that stopped you from getting into bed with Alex last time Kate was away on the West Coast…"
Neal scowled. "What did you just say?"
Castle mumbled something under his breath, pretending to look innocent.
But before Neal could press him further—
Click.
The office door swung open.
A tall, blonde woman walked in, her high ponytail neatly tied back, dressed in an impeccably tailored suit that accentuated her professional confidence.
Sarah Ellis had arrived.
If ever there was a woman who embodied the definition of sharp, it was her.
With a cold, focused expression, she stepped inside, radiating the kind of authority that made people sit up straight.
She was breathtaking—the kind of woman who could walk into a room and command attention without even trying.
However, both Castle and Neal had seen too many strong, career-driven women in their lives to be particularly awed.
Castle lived with one—Beckett.
And then there was Gianna, who had only become more terrifying since becoming a mother.
Not to mention Paula, his former agent; Jo Martinez, Henry Morgan's formidable girlfriend; and an entire army of powerful women in their circle.
So while Castle appreciated Sarah's beauty, he wasn't exactly blown away.
Still, he was looking forward to the show.
He almost managed to fade into the background, ready to secretly watch the inevitable clash between Sarah and Neal.
But fate had other plans.
As soon as Sarah entered, she immediately spotted Castle.
And to his utter disbelief—
"Castle? Oh my god, I had no idea you'd be here!"
Her entire demeanor shifted in an instant.
The cold, professional mask vanished, replaced by a bright, almost fangirl-like smile.
Castle, still processing this unexpected development, was momentarily speechless.
Neal, too, was thrown off.
He had expected Sarah to storm in and immediately start grilling him about the painting—not greet Castle like an old friend.
Sarah stepped forward, completely ignoring Neal, and extended a hand to Castle.
"I've read all your books! I'm a huge fan!"
Castle blinked.
Wait—what?
Of all the scenarios he had predicted, this wasn't one of them.
He had planned to be a silent spectator, gleefully enjoying Neal's suffering.
Instead, he was now part of the show.
And worse—
There was no way he could sit back and gawk anymore.
His own public image was now at stake.
After exchanging pleasantries with Sarah, Castle quickly realized he had no choice but to excuse himself.
Maintaining his "celebrity author" persona, he smiled politely and told her, "I'll let you two have some privacy. Sounds like you have important business to discuss."
With that, he begrudgingly left the office, stepping into the lounge where John was watching over the kids.
John took one look at Castle's utterly defeated expression and raised an eyebrow.
"What happened? You look like someone stole your favorite toy."
Castle slumped onto a couch.
"She's a fan."
John frowned. "Who?"
"Sarah. The insurance lady. She's read all my books. Recognized me on sight. Called me her favorite author. I had no choice—I had to leave the office so they could talk."
John snorted. "So, let me get this straight… You were dying to watch them argue, but instead, you got guilt-tripped into leaving?"
Castle groaned.
"I got played, man. She totally tricked me. She wanted me out of the room so I wouldn't overhear the negotiation—and I fell for it like an idiot."
John smirked. "Maybe she's just that good."
Castle buried his face in his hands.
"I wanted to see the drama! I live for this stuff! And now, I'll never know what happens in there!"
John chuckled. "Well, at least you learned something today."
Castle lifted his head, looking utterly defeated. "Yeah? And what's that?"
John grinned.
"Even the best tricksters get tricked sometimes."
Meanwhile, back in the office, Neal—now completely alone with Sarah—let out a long sigh.
"Alright, let's get this over with," he muttered.
Sarah simply smiled, taking a seat across from him.
"Don't worry, Neal. I always get what I'm looking for."
