Cherreads

Chapter 1034 - Chapter 1144: Heartache and Regret

Neal had seen through Sarah's trick the moment she used her "Castle fan" excuse to distract his meddling friend. But because he had no desire to deal with Castle sitting in his office, smirking and waiting for drama, he had chosen to stay silent, letting his so-called "friend" walk straight into the trap.

Unlike the original version of his life that Castle had once seen on TV, Neal was no longer a reckless playboy using art theft as a form of escapism. He wasn't holding onto the stolen painting because of some unresolved tension with Sarah—he simply didn't want to deal with the hassle of constantly being chased by insurance investigators.

Now that his record was clean, he had legitimate work, and—thanks to Castle—he had managed to hold onto a fair share of valuable artwork. So, when Sarah showed up, Neal had already made up his mind: it was time to return the damn painting and get some peace.

Castle, of course, had laughed at the very idea, calling him spineless for even considering giving up the painting. So, naturally, Neal hadn't warned Castle that he was being played.

Once Castle had been successfully lured out of the office, Neal quickly struck a deal with Sarah.

He would arrange for the stolen painting to be returned soon—but in exchange, she had to guarantee that neither she nor her company would ever come after him again for any other stolen artworks.

After all, if word got out that Sarah had successfully reclaimed a stolen masterpiece from the Neal Caffrey, what was stopping other insurance companies from hiring her to come knocking for everything else he had ever taken?

Or worse, what if her own company decided to send her back for round two?

So Neal's offer was simple: one time only. Take the painting, and we're done.

Sarah, being sharp as ever, instantly realized that Neal was no longer the same man she had once chased across Europe. His priorities had shifted, and he no longer thought like a thief.

For her, this was a win-win.

She would fulfill her mission, reclaim the stolen artwork, and secure a hefty bonus from her company—all with minimal effort.

So, without hesitation, she accepted Neal's terms.

The entire negotiation was over in minutes.

There was no flirtation. No lingering tension.

Certainly none of the sparks that Castle and Gianna had been so eager to witness.

Neal, feeling triumphant, left his office to gloat in the lounge where Castle and John were waiting.

Castle, on the other hand, was devastated.

Not only had he been tricked by Sarah, but he had also completely misread Neal's relationship with her!

It finally hit him—this version of Neal had never gone through the heartbreak of Kate's death. He had never been forced to work as a glorified FBI consultant. He had never bonded with Sarah over high-stakes art heists and double-crosses.

In other words…

The entire reason Castle had come here to watch some juicy drama had never even existed in this timeline!

Castle groaned in frustration.

Not only did I get tricked, but I got hyped up over nothing?!

This was painful.

Even worse?

Gianna was definitely going to laugh at him when she found out.

If he had known things would turn out this way, he wouldn't have bothered coming at all!

Not only had he failed to witness any drama, but he had become the laughingstock instead.

Neal, basking in his victory, was grinning ear to ear.

Castle had practically been salivating over the chance to see Neal suffer, and now?

The tables had turned.

For the first time in years, Castle looked genuinely defeated.

John, holding little Eleanor in his arms, was also thoroughly enjoying the sight of his usually smug friend looking so utterly crushed.

"Let me get this straight," John said, amusement clear in his voice. "You came here expecting a front-row seat to some juicy drama… but instead, you got played?"

Castle groaned, slumping in his chair. "I was set up, man. That woman is dangerous."

John chuckled. "I think the real problem is that you let your own ego get in the way. You just couldn't resist the attention, could you?"

Castle buried his face in his hands.

"I can never tell Gianna about this. She'll never let me live it down."

John smirked. "You do realize she's going to find out anyway, right?"

Neal, meanwhile, was positively radiant.

Finally, finally, Castle had been put in his place.

The man had spent years stirring up trouble, constantly poking his nose into other people's business just to see what would happen.

Now, he had walked straight into a trap of his own making.

And Neal was loving it.

He reached down and picked up baby Alex, gently bouncing the sleepy infant in his arms.

"You know," Neal said, feigning deep thought, "I was considering having a kid with Kate soon. But then Gianna called and told her she had to work for Beckett's campaign office. So there goes that plan."

John laughed, adjusting Eleanor in his arms.

"Oh yeah, definitely sounds like Gianna," he said. "She is a perfectionist, after all. And let's be real—every woman in that office is basically a badass in her own right."

Neal sighed dramatically. "Yeah, yeah, I get it. They don't need me in their all-female team. But, I did try to join. Even offered my services. But Gianna rejected me, saying my ridiculously good looks would be a 'distraction' in the workplace."

John outright laughed. "That's… honestly so Gianna."

Castle, still sulking, perked up slightly at Neal's words.

"So, let me get this straight," Castle said, a glimmer of amusement returning to his eyes. "You applied to work with them, and they turned you down because you're too handsome?"

Neal nodded solemnly.

Castle couldn't help it—he burst out laughing.

It was just so ridiculous.

"Oh my god," Castle wheezed. "That's the most Neal thing I've ever heard!"

Even John was shaking his head, grinning.

Neal just smirked.

"I mean, can you blame them?" he said, gesturing to his face.

Castle rolled his eyes.

And just like that, the sulking was over.

Even when he lost, Castle always managed to find something hilarious to latch onto.

"Alright, alright," Castle sighed. "I guess getting played by Sarah wasn't that bad. At least I got to watch you get rejected for being too pretty."

Neal chuckled. "See? There's always a silver lining, Castle."

John, shaking his head in amusement, looked down at Eleanor, who had completely passed out in his arms.

It was rare for the three of them to just sit and talk like this.

For once, there were no life-or-death situations. No crazy heists. No criminal plots.

Just three friends—and two tiny humans—hanging out.

Castle, realizing this too, smirked.

"Alright, enough about me getting tricked. Let's talk about something really important…"

Neal raised an eyebrow. "Oh?"

Castle leaned forward.

"When are you finally going to pop the question to Kate?"

Neal groaned.

And just like that—

Castle was back to being his usual meddling self.

More Chapters