Chapter 20: The Hard Choices
[Quarry Camp — Day 12, Morning]
Daryl had the pickaxe before anyone could stop him.
He crossed the clearing in four strides, the tool raised over his right shoulder, and the trajectory of his swing would have put the pointed end through Jim's skull if Rick hadn't caught the shaft mid-arc. The impact jarred Rick's arms — I could see the shock travel through his shoulders — but his grip held, and for three locked seconds the two men stood frozen in a tableau that summarized the argument the camp was about to have.
"He's bit." Daryl's voice was flat. Informational. The same tone he'd use to say the sky is blue or fire is hot. "You know what that means."
"He's alive." Rick's counter, equally flat, equally certain. "We don't kill the living."
"He won't be living. Not for long. And when he turns, he turns hungry." Daryl pulled at the pickaxe. Rick held. "You wanna wait for that? Wait for him to come at us in the night? At the kids?"
Shane appeared between them. Not intervening — positioning. His body occupied the geometric center of the dispute, close enough to grab either man, his hands loose at his sides in the ready posture of a law enforcement officer trained to de-escalate while maintaining tactical options. But his face told a different story than his body — his eyes were on Rick, and the calculation behind them wasn't about Jim at all. It was about who controlled the narrative. Who decided.
"Nobody's killing anybody." Shane's voice carried the cadence of authority he'd worn for two months and was now wearing over the top of Rick's like a coat that didn't fit. "We handle this as a group."
"He's bit, Shane—"
"I heard you. Put the damn pickaxe down."
Daryl held the tool for three more seconds. Then his arms lowered, the shaft dropping to his side with the contained reluctance of a man who'd made a decision and been overruled and was marking the moment in the ledger where he kept track of everyone else's mistakes.
Jim sat in the camp chair. He hadn't moved during the confrontation — hadn't flinched when Daryl swung, hadn't spoken when Rick caught the shaft, hadn't reacted when Shane stepped in. His eyes were open and his face was slack and the fever had advanced another degree since sunrise, visible in the sheen of sweat on his forehead and the slight tremor in his hands.
He looked like a man who'd accepted his sentence and was waiting for the court to decide the method.
"It should be his choice."
My voice. I hadn't planned to speak — the words came from the same place that had guided me through Guillermo's nursing home and the guts walk and every other moment when the gap between knowing and doing had compressed to nothing.
Heads turned. Rick. Shane. Daryl. Dale, standing at the RV door. Jacqui, kneeling beside Jim with a wet cloth that she'd been pressing to his forehead. The camp, gathered in a rough semicircle, carrying the particular attention of people who'd survived a night that had killed four of their number and weren't sure which philosophy would keep them alive for the next one.
"He's the one dying," I said. "He's the one who gets to decide how he faces it."
The silence that followed was loaded with the weight of moral positions jockeying for space. Daryl's position: mercy kill, pragmatic, prevent the risk. Rick's position: preserve life, maintain humanity, don't cross the line. Shane's position: whatever consolidated his authority, framed as strength.
Jim's position: nobody had asked.
"Jim." I crouched beside the chair. Close enough to see the veins in his temples, the yellow tinge at the corners of his eyes. Close enough to smell the fever — a specific, sour sweetness that lived underneath normal human scent and meant the body was cooking itself from the inside. "What do you want?"
His eyes focused. The question had cut through the fog — not because it was brilliant, but because it was the first question anyone had directed at him rather than about him since Jacqui had found the bite.
"I want..." His voice cracked. He swallowed, tried again. "I want to believe there's still a chance. The CDC. If they've got doctors, scientists — maybe they can do something."
"There's no cure for this." Daryl, blunt.
"Then maybe I die on the road instead of in a camp chair." Jim's jaw tightened — a ghost of strength surfacing through the fever. "My wife died running. My boys died running. I'd rather die moving than sitting."
Rick looked at me. The look held a question that was larger than Jim — it was about direction, about where this group went next, about the argument that had been building since Rick's return: who leads, and where.
"The CDC," Rick said. "We go to the CDC."
"Fort Benning." Shane, immediate. "Military base, walls, soldiers. The CDC is a building full of scientists in the middle of a dead city."
"Scientists who might have answers."
"Answers don't stop bullets. Walls stop bullets."
The debate cracked open along the fault line that had been forming since Rick stepped out of the cube van. Shane's pragmatism versus Rick's hope. Survival by retreat versus survival by understanding. The camp split — not evenly, not cleanly, but perceptibly, bodies shifting orientation toward one man or the other, the unconscious alignment of people choosing who to follow.
Dale spoke from the RV steps. "If there's any chance — any chance — that someone at the CDC understands this thing, we owe it to everyone we've lost to find out." His voice was steady and carried the specific gravity of a man whose moral compass had survived sixty-three years of calibration and wasn't about to be shaken by a committee vote. "Amy died last night. Ed died. Two others died. We bury them, and then we go find out why."
The words landed. Not because Dale was the loudest voice, but because he was the voice that carried the least agenda. He didn't want power. He didn't want control. He wanted to understand, and that desire, in a world that had stopped making sense, was the closest thing to a compass anyone had.
Shane's jaw worked. The calculation was visible — fight this and lose ground, or concede and regroup. He chose the latter with the compressed fury of a man adding another entry to the list of things Rick Grimes had taken from him.
"Fine. CDC. But when it's a dead end, we go to Benning. No arguments."
"Agreed." Rick extended his hand. Shane looked at it the way Daryl had looked at Rick's hand after the Merle news — weighing the gesture, measuring what it cost and what it bought. He shook.
---
The graves took two hours.
Jim had dug them before the attack — four holes in the ridge behind the camp, a neat row, the dirt piled beside each one with the mechanical precision of a man performing work whose purpose he understood on a level below consciousness. The irony was thick enough to choke on: the graves Jim had dug in his premonition were now being filled by the dead the premonition had anticipated.
Amy went into the ground first. Andrea wouldn't let anyone else carry her sister — she'd lifted Amy herself, cradled against her chest, and walked the distance from the camp to the ridge in a straight line that didn't waver. She lowered Amy into the grave with the terrible gentleness of a person performing the last act of care they would ever perform for someone they loved, and she stood at the edge as the dirt went in, and her face was dry, and the dryness was worse than any tears.
I stood at Ed's grave. Carol stood beside me. Her expression was the one I'd expected — not grief, not relief. Something between the two, a compound emotion that didn't have a name because the English language hadn't needed one until the apocalypse had created situations where a woman could bury the man who'd beaten her and feel loss and liberation in the same breath.
I put my hand on her shoulder. One squeeze. Brief. Not comfort — acknowledgment. I know what this is. I know it's complicated. I'm not going to make you explain it.
Carol's hand came up and covered mine for one second. Then she stepped forward, picked up a shovel, and threw the first dirt herself.
---
The caravan formed by noon. Dale's RV. Shane's Jeep. Rick in the car Morales had been using. The cube van, loaded with supplies, driven by T-Dog. Everything that mattered packed into four vehicles and pointed south toward Atlanta and the building that held either answers or ashes.
Jim lay in the RV's back bedroom, on the cot where Dale usually slept. Jacqui sat beside him, pressing a cloth to his forehead. The fever had climbed another degree — his skin was hot to the touch and his eyes were glassy and the lucidity came and went like a radio signal fading in and out of range.
I checked my bag. Bat — bent, still functional, but degrading. The bend at the midpoint meant the sweet spot had shifted, and the next hard swing might fold the shaft entirely. I'd need a new weapon soon. The gym bag — torn, lighter than it had been before the cache supplies were consumed, carrying the essentials and nothing more. The folding knife. The pocket knife. The radio. The first aid kit.
No bandage on my arm. The skin beneath my sleeve was clean, unmarked, carrying no evidence of the scratch that had tested the fundamental question of my existence in this world and answered it in the affirmative.
I can take risks others can't. The thought sat in my chest with a weight that was equal parts relief and responsibility. Immunity wasn't invulnerability — a walker could still tear me apart, bleed me out, crush my skull. But the pathogen that turned every corpse in this world into a predator couldn't touch me. I was outside the equation that governed every other human being alive.
The CDC would confirm what I already knew: everyone was infected. Everyone carried the virus. Death meant reanimation, bite or no bite. Jenner would tell them, and the revelation would break some of them and harden others, and then the building would try to kill them all.
I had to figure out how to get them out.
The caravan's engines started — a ragged chorus of gasoline combustion that sounded like civilization's last breath — and the quarry camp shrank in the side mirror as we pulled onto the gravel road that led to the highway that led to Atlanta that led to the CDC that led to whatever came next.
I climbed into the RV's passenger seat beside Dale and buckled in.
"Ready?" Dale asked.
The CDC was a trap. Jenner was a man who'd lost his wife and his hope and his reason to continue, and he'd sealed the building to burn because he'd decided that survival wasn't worth the cost. I knew this. I'd carried the knowledge since Day One, and the knowledge was a weapon I couldn't use until the moment it mattered.
"Ready."
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0