The news of Bramwell's fall came up the ridge road the following spring, and Alaric heard it first, which was only right, since he had predicted it to within a few months nearly five years before.
He heard it from a Crown messenger, a young man in a good cloak who arrived at the gatehouse on a lathered horse with a sealed letter for the council of Argenton, and who waited in the courtyard while the castellan read it, and who seemed slightly unnerved by the expression on the old man's face as he did so.
It was not triumph. Thomas, coming down the lane from the tally-bench at a run because someone had shouted Crown rider, saw the expression from twenty yards off and slowed to a walk. It was not satisfaction. It was something much older and wearier than either — the face of a man who has watched a wheel come round to exactly where he said it would, and who had hoped, against all his own reasoning, to be wrong.
"He is out," said Alaric, without looking up from the letter. "The March is taken into the King's hand pending a new appointment. His creditors moved at Candlemas. Bramwell surrendered his commission at Lady Day." He folded the letter. "Within five years, I said. It has been a little under. I was too generous."
The council met that afternoon. It was not a long meeting. There was not much to decide.
The formula would go on. That was the first thing, and Victoria said it before anyone else could, in her flattest tally-bench voice. The settlement was with the March, not with Bramwell; it had been written that way on purpose, at Cecily's insistence, so that it would outlast him. The payment due at midsummer would go to the King's receiver until a new lord was named, and then to the new lord, on the published arithmetic, to the penny. Nothing changed.
"Except who's on the other end of it," said Diccon.
"Except that."
"And we don't know who."
"No," said Alaric. "We do not. The Crown will appoint whoever the Crown wishes to reward, and we will find out when he arrives. I have some guesses. None of them are pleasant." He laid his hands flat on the bench, and Thomas noticed that the shake in them was worse than it had been at Candlemas. "What I can tell this council is that whoever it is will have read the formula before he sets foot here, and will have read about Bramwell, and will know exactly how much this town pays and exactly how little that is compared to what it earns. Bramwell came to us desperate. The next man will come to us ambitious. I am not certain which is worse."
Nobody said anything for a while.
Then Diccon, who had been fidgeting, cleared his throat.
"I'm going to say it," he said, "because someone has to, and you'll all think it and not say it. There'll be a bonfire tonight. In the lower parish. People want one. The man spent seven years trying to strangle us, and he's gone, and they want a fire." He looked round the table. "I think they should have one. I think we should let them. I might go."
"No," said Cecily.
Diccon's face went red. "It's not your place to —"
"It's my settlement," said Cecily. "I wrote it. I sat across a table from him at Ashfield and negotiated it, and I watched him take every point he could get and give away every point he had to, and at the end he stood up and bowed to me as an equal." Her voice did not rise. "He's a man who's lost his house. He has a wife and two children. I am not going to stand round a fire in the lower parish cheering about it, and I don't think this council should either."
"He brought thirty men to our gate."
"He brought thirty witnesses. Alaric said so. And then he told us the truth to our faces, which most lords never do." Cecily turned to Victoria. "You talked to him. Alone. You never told us what he said. Tell them now. Was he a man we should be lighting fires about?"
All eyes went to Victoria.
She sat very still. Thomas, beside her, could feel her deciding.
"No," she said at last. "He wasn't."
That was all she said. She did not explain. But the way she said it, flat and final, with her eyes on the table, closed the matter more surely than anything Cecily had said, and Diccon looked at her for a while and then sat back and did not mention the fire again.
There was a fire anyway, that night, in the lower parish. Nobody from the council went. Thomas heard it from the cottage step, the distant noise of it, singing and shouting, and saw the glow on the low cloud over the dye-works, and did not go down.
Edmund had written the summary.
He was twelve. He had been at Alaric's desk since the messenger came, while the council sat, copying the Crown letter in fair, and then, without being asked, drawing up a short account of what it meant — the March in the King's hand, the formula unchanged, the midsummer payment to the receiver — in his neat clear hand, on a single sheet, for the council's book.
Alaric read it after the meeting, standing at the desk, leaning on his stick.
He read it twice. Edmund stood beside him and did not breathe.
"Where did you learn to put the conclusion first?" Alaric said at last.
"From you. You always do. In the case. You put what it means at the top and then the reasons."
"I do." Alaric set the sheet down. "Most clerks put it at the bottom, because they are afraid of being wrong, and if it is at the bottom nobody reads that far." He looked at the boy. "You put it at the top. You are not afraid of being wrong. That is very useful in a clerk, and very dangerous in a man, and you are going to have to learn the difference."
Edmund did not know what to say to that. He went red.
"It is good," said Alaric. "It goes in the book as it is. In your name." He paused. "I will tell the council you wrote it. All of them. Your father too."
He did. He said it at the next meeting, plainly, as an item of business, and Thomas sat at the table and heard it, and looked at the sheet in his son's hand, and said that it was very good, out loud, in front of everyone.
Edmund, on the gallery stair — he was still on the gallery stair; he would be on it, in one way or another, for years — heard his father say it. He sat on the third step with his arms round his knees and held it, the way he held the coin, and did not move until the council rose.
Victoria did not sleep much that night.
Thomas woke at some hour and found her sitting up in the dark, with her knees drawn up under the blanket, looking at nothing.
"You're thinking about his children," he said.
"I asked Corradino," said Victoria. "The night before he left. I asked him what would happen to the family. He told me the usual way and the unusual way." She did not turn her head. "The usual way, he sells what isn't entailed and then what is. The wife's people stop answering. The boy is married to whoever will pay most for a name and despises it for the rest of his life." A pause. "And I sent the letter anyway."
"We sent it. The council."
"I wrote it." She was silent for a while. "His daughter checked our sums. Isabel. She wrote a line at the bottom of his letter. I was looking for some. I pinned it on the wall at the tally-bench and it's still there." She pressed the heels of her hands against her eyes. "She'll be thirteen. Fourteen. I keep thinking about what the usual way is for a girl."
Thomas did not say anything wise. He had learned not to.
He sat up beside her in the dark instead, and put his arm round her shoulders, and she let him, and they stayed like that until the window began to go grey, neither of them saying anything, both of them thinking about a man in a good coat who had eaten pottage at their table and let their youngest son fall asleep on his arm, and who was, tonight, somewhere in England, no longer anybody's lord.
