Chapter 3 : The Gang Gets Racist
Paddy's Pub, South Philadelphia — Early August, 2005
Griffin has been behind the bar for nine days when the first scheme lands.
Nine days of learning the rhythms. Dennis arrives between 11 and noon, never orders before 1, checks his hair in the mirror seventeen times per shift — Griffin counted one Tuesday out of boredom. Mac arrives whenever Dennis does, a satellite locked in orbit. Charlie is always already here; Griffin suspects he sleeps in the back office some nights, though the smell from that room makes it hard to confirm. Dee appears mid-afternoon, stays until someone insults her, leaves, comes back an hour later pretending the leaving never happened.
Nine days, and the bar has had an average of four paying customers per night. The register barely covers the electricity. Griffin has earned sixty dollars total and supplemented it with tips that amount to a pile of quarters and one Canadian dime.
Tonight is different. Griffin knows it the moment he arrives for his shift, because there are people in the bar.
Not the usual people. Not the old man with the Yuengling or the couple who wandered in last Wednesday thinking it was a different bar and left with visible regret. These are new customers — a group of six Black men in their twenties and thirties, drinking, talking, laughing at a volume that suggests they're actually having a good time, which in Paddy's is unprecedented.
Griffin pours a round of Sam Adams and processes what he's seeing.
Season one, episode one. It's happening.
The Gang is clustered at the end of the bar, and the argument has already started. Griffin can hear it in pieces, a collage of terrible reasoning delivered with absolute confidence.
"All I'm saying," Dennis says, holding a finger up like he's about to deliver a TED Talk, "is that the dynamic has changed, and we need to capitalize on the dynamic."
"The dynamic," Mac repeats.
"The DYNAMIC, Mac. The customer base is shifting. We need to shift with it."
"You mean because the bar is—" Mac lowers his voice to a stage whisper that carries thirty feet. "—because there's Black guys here now?"
"I'm not saying that. I'm not saying— Dee, tell him I'm not saying that."
"You're definitely saying that," Dee says.
"I'm saying the DEMOGRAPHIC—"
"You're making it about race."
"I'M making it about race? Mac, you literally just said 'Black guys.'"
"Because they ARE—"
"You can't just SAY—"
"Why not? It's descriptive—"
"It's REDUCTIVE, Mac—"
Griffin pours another round for the actual customers and says nothing. This is the pilot. The first episode. The one where four people who've probably never examined a single assumption in their lives are confronted with the mildest possible catalyst — new customers who don't look like them — and respond by turning it into a sociological crisis.
He remembers watching this episode for the first time on a laptop in Columbus, a decade from now in a timeline that doesn't exist anymore. He remembers thinking it was sharp. Brave, even, for a pilot. How the show used the Gang's ignorance as a mirror.
He pours a whiskey for the man at the end of the bar who ordered neat, no ice. The man says thanks and goes back to his conversation. Normal interaction. The kind of thing that happens in bars a million times a night.
The Gang, fifteen feet away, is acting like the bar has been invaded.
---
By 9 PM, Dee has introduced herself to Terrell.
Griffin watches from behind the taps while he washes glasses. Terrell is tall, athletic, friendly in the easy way of someone who walked into a bar expecting a beer and not a performance. Dee sits across from him with the energy of a woman who is about to prove she is Not Racist by being the most aggressively welcoming person in the building, which is its own kind of racism, but Dee has never met a social grace she couldn't strangle.
"So, where are you from?" Dee asks, and Griffin can hear the capital letters on every word.
"Germantown."
"Oh, Germantown! That's so— I love Germantown."
"You been?"
"Not... specifically. But I've heard so many great things."
Terrell takes a sip of his beer. He's polite. Patient. He doesn't know yet that patience is a non-renewable resource in this building.
Dennis, meanwhile, has moved to a table near the door where he's positioned himself to be visible from every angle. He's running calculations — Griffin can tell from the slight tension in his jaw, the way his eyes move between Terrell and the group and Dee with the mechanical precision of someone mapping a room for advantage.
"We should do a promotion," Dennis announces to Mac, loud enough for everyone to hear. "Something that shows we're a welcoming establishment."
"Like what?"
"I don't know, Mac. Something tasteful. Something that says 'Paddy's Pub is for everyone.'"
"A banner?"
"Yes. A banner. With the right... imagery."
"Like a— like a diversity banner?"
"Don't say diversity like that."
"Like what?"
"Like you're reading it off a pamphlet you don't understand."
Charlie emerges from the back with something in a bucket Griffin doesn't examine. He sees the new customers and his eyebrows go up.
"Oh, cool. New people. You guys want some of this?"
He holds up the bucket. Nobody wants any of it.
"It's homemade," Charlie adds, as if that helps.
Griffin collects empties from the new customers' table and replaces them with fresh bottles. Two of the men are watching the Gang's cluster at the bar with the kind of cautious amusement that comes from recognizing you've walked into someone else's crisis.
"Is it always like this?" one of them asks Griffin.
"I've been here nine days and yes."
The man laughs. His friend shakes his head.
"Weird bar."
"You have no idea."
---
The scheme collapses at exactly the pace Griffin remembers.
Dennis's plan to "rebrand" Paddy's as multicultural results in a promotional poster that Mac designs on a napkin using stick figures that are, charitably, ethnically ambiguous and, uncharitably, grounds for a civil rights complaint. Dee's conversation with Terrell deteriorates when she asks him if he played basketball, then tries to recover by asking about jazz, then overcorrects into a monologue about how she "doesn't see color" that makes Terrell look at Griffin behind the bar with an expression that translates clearly to is she serious right now.
Griffin dries a glass. The answer to Terrell's unspoken question is yes, and it will never stop being yes.
By 10:30, the new customers are gone. Not because anyone asked them to leave. Because the Gang is exhausting to be near, and exhaustion doesn't discriminate.
Terrell shakes Griffin's hand on the way out.
"Good luck, man," Terrell says, and he means it in the specific way that people mean it when they're glad they get to leave a situation and you don't.
"Appreciate it."
The door shuts. The bar is empty again. Dennis is explaining to Mac why the promotion failed, and the explanation involves Mac's napkin art but not Dennis's behavior, because Dennis Reynolds has never been the problem in any story he tells about himself.
"We almost had something," Dennis says. "We were on the verge of a genuine... cultural moment."
"I think my poster was good," Mac says.
"Your poster was a hate crime, Mac."
"It was INCLUSIVE—"
"Dee ruined it," Dennis says, pivoting. "She always ruins it."
"I RUINED it? I was the only one talking to them like normal people—"
"You asked him about JAZZ, Dee—"
"I was making CONVERSATION—"
The argument continues. It will continue until they get bored or drunk or both, and then they'll leave, and tomorrow they'll come back and have no memory of learning anything from tonight.
Because they won't have learned anything. That's the rule. The fundamental law of this universe that no amount of intervention or goodwill or common sense can override: these five people do not change. They cannot be taught, persuaded, or shamed into growth. They are a closed system running on narcissism, delusion, and cheap beer, and the loop never breaks.
Griffin watched it for entertainment. From a couch. Through a screen.
He's not watching through a screen anymore.
---
Paddy's Pub — 12:40 AM
Griffin locks the front door. The dead bolt sticks — he has to lift the door slightly on its hinges and shove, a trick he learned on night three. The key turns. The bolt slides home.
He stands outside.
The street is quiet. South Philly at midnight is a different animal than South Philly at noon — darker, cooler, the humidity finally breaking enough that the air feels like air instead of warm soup. A car passes on 8th Street with its windows down and hip-hop playing, bass heavy enough that Griffin feels it in his ribs. A cat crosses the sidewalk twenty feet ahead, pauses under a streetlight, decides Griffin isn't interesting, and disappears between two parked cars.
He breathes.
Terrell was real. That's the thing he can't stop turning over as he starts walking north toward the apartment. On the show, Terrell was a guest actor. A plot device. A mirror held up to the Gang's ignorance so the audience could laugh at the reflection. He appeared, served his narrative function, and vanished into the show's memory hole where guest characters go to be forgotten.
Tonight, Terrell walked into a bar because he wanted a beer. He sat down. He talked to Dee because she sat across from him and wouldn't stop talking first. He endured forty-five minutes of being treated as a social experiment by people who thought they were being progressive while being everything but. And then he left, and tomorrow he'd wake up and remember the weird bar in South Philly where the owners acted like they'd never met a Black person before, and it would be a story he'd tell at a cookout, something to shake his head about.
He's a real person. They're all real people. Every customer, every bystander, every Cricket and Waitress and Lawyer who the show treated as supporting cast in the Gang's psychodrama — they're here, they're breathing, and the punchlines land on them first.
Griffin served drinks through all of it. Wiped the bar. Collected the empties. Watched the trainwreck happen at the exact speed and in the exact order he remembered and did absolutely nothing because he's the new bartender and new bartenders don't rewrite pilots.
The apartment building comes into view. Griffin takes the stairs two at a time — a habit from the old body that this body has apparently adopted. He unlocks the door, steps inside, drops the keys on the milk crate.
The apartment is dark and small and it smells like plaster dust and the cereal he hasn't replaced yet. He doesn't turn on the light. He goes to the window and opens it, and the night air pushes in, carrying the sound of distant traffic and a siren that could be three blocks or thirty.
If I could rate that disaster, I'd give it a D. Embarrassment only. No lasting damage. Forgotten by next week.
He doesn't have a rating system. He doesn't have anything except a head full of episode guides and a body that pours beer for minimum wage in a bar run by people he's studied like a anthropologist for years. But the instinct is there — the urge to categorize, to quantify the damage, to reduce what just happened to a letter grade because it's easier to process a letter than a person.
Terrell's handshake. Firm. Brief. Good luck, man.
Griffin pulls on a clean shirt and opens the mini-fridge. Empty except for a can of generic cola he bought on day three. He cracks it. The carbonation stings his tongue.
Tomorrow — he checks the flip phone, scrolling through the two contacts and zero apps — tomorrow Charlie is going to pitch something. It's early Season 1. The schemes come fast and dumb and mostly D-tier, embarrassment-grade disasters that burn hot and burn out. Low stakes. Low damage. The kind of chaos you can stand beside and stay clean.
But the show runs for seventeen seasons, and the damage gets worse, and the people who get caught in the blast radius stop being guest actors and start being people whose names Griffin doesn't know yet and can't protect.
He drains the cola. Sets the empty can on the counter. Looks out the window toward the green sign he can't see from this angle but knows is there, two blocks south, waiting.
Tomorrow Charlie pitches a scheme involving a fake pregnancy. I'll know every word before he says it.
The flip phone buzzes. A text from "Mike": "u alive bro?"
Griffin types back, one letter at a time on the number pad: "yeah."
He closes the phone. He doesn't know who Mike is. One more thing on the list — a list that's growing faster than his ability to manage it. The body's history. The contacts. The life of a person who existed before Griffin woke up wearing his face.
But that's tomorrow's problem. Tonight, he's alive in a world he knows too well and not well enough, and the bar is closed, and there's nothing left to pour.
He leaves the window open. Lies down on the mattress. Stares at the ceiling that belongs to Griffin Finch and tries not to think about the ceiling that belonged to whoever he was before the headlights crossed the median.
Sleep doesn't come easy. The mattress smells like someone else. The sirens don't stop. Somewhere south, Paddy's Pub sits dark and locked and waiting for morning, when the door will open and the yelling will start again and Griffin will pour drinks through whatever comes next.
The flip phone screen glows on the milk crate. 1:14 AM. August, 2005.
Seventeen seasons. I know every disaster between here and the end. And I'm the bartender.
He rolls over. Closes his eyes. Forces his breathing to slow until the body — this borrowed, wrong, alive body — finally lets go and drops into something that might be sleep or might be the closest thing to it this world allows.
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes.
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!