Chapter 5 : The Dead Guy and the Dread
Paddy's Pub, South Philadelphia — Late August, 2005
The key sticks in the lock the way it always does — lift, shove, turn. Griffin shoulders the front door open at 9:47 AM on a Thursday and the smell hits him three steps inside.
Sweet. Thick. Wrong in a way that bypasses conscious recognition and goes straight to the base of his skull where the old animal brain lives. His body stops before his mind catches up, one foot on the sticky floor and the other still on the threshold, and for half a second the morning light from the street cuts a bright rectangle into the bar's permanent gloom.
The man is in the back booth. Slumped sideways against the wall with his chin on his chest and one arm trailing off the edge of the seat. Gray hair. Heavy coat, which is strange for August. An empty glass on the table in front of him, tipped on its side, whatever was in it long dried into a pale ring on the wood.
Griffin doesn't move for ten seconds. He counts them.
Season one, episode six. The Gang Finds a Dead Guy.
The knowledge is there — crisp, certain, filed under "natural causes, old man, no foul play, Gang treats it as an opportunity." And the knowledge is useless because the smell is real and the body is real and the distance between knowing someone dies and standing eight feet from the proof of it is a gap no amount of episode recall can bridge.
He sets his keys on the bar. Walks to the booth. Doesn't touch anything. The man's skin has the waxy, settled look of someone who's been here for hours — since before closing, probably, tucked into the back booth where the light doesn't reach and nobody checks because nobody orders food and the back section of Paddy's hasn't been properly occupied since before Griffin arrived.
He smells like something Griffin has no reference point for. Not rot — it's too early for that. Something chemical. Something leaving.
Griffin goes behind the bar, picks up the phone, and dials 911.
The dispatcher asks him questions in a voice that's calm in the specific way that suggests she's been calm about dead bodies hundreds of times. Griffin answers. Address. Description. No, he didn't touch anything. Yes, the door was locked when he arrived. No, he doesn't know the man's name.
He hangs up and sits on the bar stool nearest the door and waits.
The Gang arrives in stages.
Mac first, through the back entrance, sweating from his morning "workout" — a series of karate moves he performs in the alley that would not survive contact with an actual opponent. He sees Griffin sitting. He sees Griffin's face.
"What?"
"Back booth."
Mac walks to the back booth. A beat. Two.
"Dude. DUDE."
"Yeah."
"Is he—"
"Yeah."
"Did you—"
"Called it in. Cops are coming."
Mac processes this with the speed and depth of a man skimming a pamphlet in a language he doesn't speak. His face cycles through shock, confusion, and a third expression that Griffin recognizes from the show — the one where Mac calculates whether a situation can be turned to his advantage.
"Do the cops have to come?"
"Mac, there's a dead person in the bar."
"I KNOW there's a dead person, but— couldn't we— what if we—"
"No."
Dennis arrives twelve minutes later, hair perfect, shirt pressed, the mask of casual indifference already set and polished. He assesses the situation the way Dennis assesses everything: with the clinical detachment of a man who believes other people's deaths are events that happen to other people.
"Well," Dennis says, straightening his cuffs. "This is an opportunity."
"It's a dead man."
"It's a dead man in OUR bar. Do you know what kind of press this could generate? Mystery. Intrigue. 'What happened at Paddy's Pub?' We could lean into it. A murder-mystery night. Themed cocktails."
"He died of natural causes, Dennis."
"You don't KNOW that."
"He's eighty years old and his glass is empty. He had a drink and died."
"That's the NARRATIVE, Griffin. I'm talking about the STORY. Stories don't have to be true — they have to be interesting."
Charlie arrives last, through a window, for reasons Griffin doesn't ask about. Charlie sees the body and his first response is: "Is that jacket leather?"
"Charlie."
"I'm just asking. If nobody's using it—"
"The man is DEAD, Charlie."
"Right. Right. Sad. Very sad. But the jacket—"
"No."
The police arrive at 10:35. Two officers — one young, one tired, both carrying the specific South Philly flatness that comes from years of responding to calls at establishments exactly like this one. They tape off the booth. They take Griffin's statement. They don't take statements from Dennis, Mac, or Charlie because all three simultaneously tried to pitch the officers on different theories about what happened, and the tired cop shut it down with a look that could strip paint.
The body goes out on a stretcher under a white sheet at 11:12 AM. The booth remains taped. The bar remains open because the cops have no reason to close it and the Gang has no intention of closing it.
Griffin pours drinks for the rest of the day. The tape stays up. Dennis spends two hours drafting a press release about "the Paddy's Pub Mystery" on a napkin. Mac argues that the dead man might have been an assassin. Charlie circles back to the jacket three more times before giving up.
Nobody talks about the man. Not who he was, not what brought him to Paddy's on his last night alive, not whether anyone is waiting for him to come home. He existed. He stopped. The Gang pivoted to entertainment before the body bag cleared the door.
---
Griffin takes his break at 3 PM.
The back step of Paddy's faces an alley that smells like dumpster runoff and cat piss, which is still better than the lingering trace of whatever death smells like in an unventilated bar. He sits on the concrete step and pulls out the flip phone and opens the contacts list.
Mike. That's it. One name. One person who knew Griffin Finch well enough to text "u alive bro?" — and Griffin still doesn't know who Mike is, hasn't called him back, hasn't investigated the life of the man whose body he's wearing because investigating means engaging and engaging means this is permanent.
He holds the phone in his lap. The screen glows with its two contacts and its nothing else. In Columbus he had — what? A mother he called on Sundays. A coworker named Dave who sometimes invited him to happy hour. A fantasy football league with guys from college whose names he's already starting to forget.
Not a lot. But more than this. More than an alley behind a bar where a man died overnight and four people treated his body like a plot point.
His thumb hovers over Mike's name. Doesn't press.
Who was Griffin Finch? What did he do, who did he know, what did he care about? And does it matter, since I'm him now whether I like it or not?
The back door opens. Charlie's head appears.
"Hey, can dead guys get you haunted? Like, is the bar haunted now?"
"No, Charlie."
"Because I've been hearing stuff in the basement and I want to know if it's the dead guy or if it's Gerald."
"It's Gerald. Gerald is a rat."
"Gerald is MORE than a rat, man."
Charlie retreats. The door bangs shut. Griffin pockets the phone and goes back inside.
The rest of the shift passes in the rhythm he's been learning for weeks — pour, wipe, listen, don't react, pour again. The tape comes down at 6 PM when Dennis decides it's "killing the aesthetic." Nobody has identified the dead man. Nobody has asked to.
Griffin closes alone. Locks up. Walks north on 8th Street through air that's still August-heavy and thick. The streetlights paint circles on the sidewalk. A SEPTA bus hisses past on Snyder Avenue, half-empty, going somewhere Griffin has never been in this body.
I know what comes next. The last episode of Season 1. Charlie's uncle.
His stride shortens. Not a conscious decision — his body responding to what his brain is already processing, the way you slow down when you see the edge of something you don't want to reach.
Charlie Got Molested. The darkest episode in the first season. The one where the show touches something real underneath the comedy and then steps back and lets the audience figure out what they just watched.
The apartment building. The stairs. The door that needs the same lift-and-shove as the bar. Griffin steps inside. Drops the keys on the milk crate.
Tomorrow. It's coming tomorrow, or the day after, or next week — the timeline isn't exact enough to pinpoint the day, but it's close, and the dread that's been sitting in his chest since the dead man's booth is already spreading, already colonizing the spaces between his ribs.
He opens the mini-fridge. Empty except for tap water in a reused bottle. His stomach has been tight since 9:47 AM and the idea of food is theoretical at best.
I've been dreading this since I recognized the timeline. Since the first week, when the calendar and the episodes and the faces all lined up and I understood that Season 1 doesn't end with a laugh.
He drinks the water standing at the counter. Sets the bottle down. Looks at the wall.
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes.
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!