Chapter 6 : Some Things You Can't Watch Clean
Paddy's Pub, South Philadelphia — Late August, 2005
Uncle Jack Kelly has hands the size of a child's, and Griffin can't stop looking at them.
The man sits at the end of the bar — Griffin's bar, the bar he's been maintaining for a month now with clean glasses and wiped surfaces and the quiet professional pride of someone who has nothing else to be proud of in this borrowed life — and orders a whiskey neat, and his fingers wrap around the glass like a smaller person's fingers on a larger person's glass, and he drinks, and he smiles at Charlie across the room, and the smile is warm and wide and Griffin's knuckles go white on the towel in his hand.
Season one, episode seven. Charlie Got Molested.
He's been bracing for this. Days of anticipatory dread that sit behind his sternum like a stone. The dead man in the booth was a stranger — sad, impersonal, a fact of mortality processed and filed. This is different. This is knowing the specific person sitting four feet away, knowing what he did, knowing that the show framed it as dark comedy and the audience processed it as dark comedy and Griffin himself, on his couch in Columbus, processed it as dark comedy — and now Uncle Jack Kelly is drinking whiskey that Griffin poured for him and the comedy is a very thin layer over something that makes Griffin's hands want to do things his brain knows are stupid.
Charlie bounces between tables with the energy of a man who has never once sat with a thought long enough to understand it. His uncle is here. His uncle is visiting. His uncle wants to reconnect. Charlie treats this the way Charlie treats everything — with enthusiasm and zero self-reflection and the kind of aggressive forward momentum that only works if you never, ever look back.
"Uncle Jack, you gotta meet Griffin — he's the new bartender, he's cool, he keeps the glasses clean which is MORE than I ever did—"
"Hello," Uncle Jack says. He extends his hand.
Griffin shakes it. The hand is small and dry and the grip is firm in the way of someone who has learned to compensate. Griffin lets go after exactly one second and picks up the bar towel again.
"Another whiskey?"
"Please."
Griffin pours. The bottle neck taps the rim of the glass — a flinch, tiny, and Uncle Jack doesn't notice because Uncle Jack is watching Charlie with an attention that has texture and weight to it, and Griffin sets the glass down and steps back to the taps and puts four feet of bar between himself and the man and breathes through his nose.
Don't react. Don't react. You're the bartender. Bartenders pour drinks and mind their business and don't assault customers based on knowledge they shouldn't have about things they didn't witness.
---
The scheme unfolds the way Griffin remembers it.
Two of Charlie's old teachers show up at Paddy's — their names don't matter, what matters is what Charlie says about them when the Gang starts digging. Mac and Dennis, operating on their own brand of deductive reasoning, decide that the teachers must have molested Charlie. The irony is thick enough to choke on: they're looking in the wrong direction, pointing at the wrong men, building a case against people who didn't do it while the man who did sits at the bar sipping whiskey and smiling.
Charlie deflects. Charlie always deflects. The show made his deflection funny — the non-sequiturs, the subject changes, the way he'd suddenly pivot to a rant about rats or the Waitress or some arcane theory about bird law. Watching it through a screen, the comedy was a cushion. You could laugh and then the episode ended and you moved on.
In person, sitting six feet from the man and ten feet from the boy — because that's what Charlie is, in the ways that count, still the boy in the room with his uncle — the deflection isn't comedy. It's architecture. Load-bearing walls of noise and chaos built over decades to keep the ground floor sealed.
Dennis runs the interrogation. He's good at it — not in the way a therapist is good at it, but in the way a narcissist is good at it, which means he asks questions that make himself feel smart rather than questions that help the person being asked. Mac backs him up with volume and misplaced confidence. Dee hovers at the margins, oscillating between genuine concern and the need to insert herself into the drama.
Charlie laughs too loud. Changes the subject. Starts talking about a scheme involving a fake lottery ticket. Griffin polishes the same glass for fifteen minutes and watches Uncle Jack watch Charlie from the end of the bar with that smile, that patient avuncular smile, and the glass in Griffin's hand is so clean it squeaks.
"You're going to wear a hole in that," Dee says, passing by with an empty tray.
Griffin puts the glass down.
"You okay? You look—"
"Fine."
Dee shrugs and moves on. She doesn't push, because Dee doesn't push on things that aren't about Dee, and Griffin's state of mind isn't about Dee, so it ceases to exist the moment she turns away.
Uncle Jack orders a third whiskey. Griffin pours it. Their eyes meet over the glass.
"Good bar," Uncle Jack says. "Charlie always did find the interesting spots."
"Yeah."
"He's a good kid. Resilient."
The word lands like a slap. Resilient. The word you use about people who survived something, said by the something they survived, in a tone of genuine affection that makes it worse because the affection might even be real, warped and toxic and entirely genuine, the way terrible people can love the people they destroy.
"He is," Griffin says, because the bartender agrees and the man holding the towel wants to break the glass and both of them live in the same body.
---
The Gang resolves it the way the Gang resolves everything: badly, incompletely, and without lasting consequence for anyone who caused harm.
The teachers are confronted. They're innocent, bewildered, vaguely traumatized by the experience. Charlie's deflection holds. Uncle Jack leaves Paddy's around 9 PM with a handshake for Charlie that Griffin sees from across the room and a wave toward the bar that Griffin does not return.
By 9:30, the Gang has moved on. Dennis is describing a woman he saw at the gym. Mac is arguing that his investigative skills were "solid in principle." Dee is rehearsing a scene from an audition she has tomorrow. Charlie is eating a piece of bread that he found somewhere Griffin doesn't want to think about.
Nobody mentions Uncle Jack. Nobody mentions what the investigation almost uncovered. Nobody mentions the word that Dennis used three hours ago — the correct word, applied to the wrong people — and nobody connects it to the man who just walked out the door with his small hands and his warm smile.
The episode is over. Season 1 is over.
Griffin pours a round for the Gang — on the house, he tells them, because it's the last week of August and the bar could use the goodwill. They don't question it. Free drinks are free drinks.
Paddy's Pub — 1:15 AM
The chairs are up. The lights are off except for the one above the bar that buzzes on a frequency that Griffin has started hearing in his sleep. He locked the door thirty minutes ago and hasn't moved.
He's sitting at the end of the bar. Uncle Jack's seat. His hand is wrapped around a beer — his first real drink since arriving in this body — and the glass is half full and warming in his grip.
The spot where Uncle Jack sat is on his left. Griffin stares at it for a while, then gets up, walks behind the bar, pulls out the cleaning supplies, and starts scrubbing. The wood is old and soft and absorbs everything — spills, stains, the residue of a thousand nights of bad decisions. He scrubs with a brush he found in the back, working the grain, pressing hard enough that the bristles bend flat.
The spot gets lighter. Cleaner than the rest of the bar by a shade. He keeps going.
Seven episodes. Seven predictions. One hundred percent accuracy across an entire season of television that isn't television anymore, that's reality now, that's real people and real damage and a real man drinking real whiskey at this bar while his nephew laughed too loud and changed the subject.
His forearm burns from the scrubbing. He switches hands.
What kind of person watches all of this and stays?
The question has been forming since the dead man in the booth — maybe since the pilot, since Terrell walked out and Griffin served drinks through the aftermath. But Uncle Jack crystallized it. Sharpened the edges. Made it specific.
Griffin knows everything. He knows what happens to Cricket — the teeth, the degradation, the slow-motion collapse from priest to wreck. He knows what happens when Frank arrives — the money, the chaos, the upgrade from D-tier disasters to schemes that damage real people in real ways. He knows the D.E.N.N.I.S. System and who it targets and what it costs and exactly how many women will be psychologically dismantled by a man Griffin serves drinks to every day.
And he's the bartender. He polishes glasses and collects tips and goes home to a studio apartment with a water stain on the wall and a contact list of exactly one name he doesn't recognize.
You can't just watch. You can't. Not forever. Not knowing what you know.
But what's the alternative? Warn people? The Cassandra problem — nobody believes the pessimistic bartender. Intervene directly? He has no power, no money, no connections, and the Gang is a self-reinforcing system that ejects external variables like antibodies fighting an infection. Leave? Go where? He has three hundred dollars beyond rent and a body with no history and no credentials beyond "can pour a beer."
The beer in his hand has gone flat. He drinks it anyway. The taste is nothing special — cheap lager from a keg that needs replacing — but it's the first drink he's chosen to have, not poured for someone else, and the distinction matters in a way he can't articulate.
There has to be something between watching and leaving. Some angle. Some use for the seventeen seasons of hindsight rattling around in a brain that belongs to a dead man from Ohio.
He finishes the beer. Sets the glass in the sink. Doesn't wash it — leaves it there, a single unwashed glass in a bar he's kept cleaner than it's been in years, because tonight he's too tired to be the only person who cares about the glasses.
The cleaning supplies go back under the bar. The light buzzes. The spot where Uncle Jack sat is lighter than the rest of the wood — a pale rectangle that'll fade when the grime builds up again, which it will, because grime always builds up in places like this.
Griffin grabs his jacket from the hook by the office door. Checks the lock. Checks it again.
The September air meets him on the sidewalk — cooler than August by a degree, a promise that fall is possible, that seasons change even in a universe where people don't. He walks north. The flip phone buzzes in his pocket.
A text from Mike: "haven't heard from u. everything ok?"
Griffin types back: "yeah. new job. busy."
A pause. Then: "cool. beers sometime?"
Griffin stares at the screen. The cursor blinks. Mike — whoever Mike is — wants beers. With a man who doesn't exist anymore, wearing his face and living in his apartment and sleeping on his mattress.
"sure," Griffin types. "soon."
He pockets the phone and keeps walking. The bar is behind him. Season 1 is behind him. The space between seasons — a few months of relative quiet before Frank Reynolds shows up and multiplies every disaster by a factor of money and guns and a man who says "I know a guy" the way other people say "good morning" — stretches ahead.
Somewhere in that space, there's an answer to the question he asked himself on Uncle Jack's barstool. Not tonight. Tonight, the answer is just the walk home and the apartment and the mattress and the ceiling he's stopped calling wrong because wrong implies there's a right one to go back to.
But the question keeps its shape. Carries weight. Follows him up the stairs and through the door and into the dark room where the water stain spreads.
What kind of person watches all of this and stays?
The kind who's going to find out what a bartender with foreknowledge can actually do — once the right bottle and the right night line up and the question answers itself.
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes.
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!