Chapter 17 : The First Bet
Paddy's Pub, South Philadelphia — February, 2006
Dennis is wearing a track suit.
Not ironically — Dennis Reynolds does not do irony about his appearance. This is a deliberate choice, a costume selected to match the role he's cast himself in for this week's performance: the welfare recipient. He stands in the center of the bar in a polyester tracksuit he found at Goodwill and holds it like he's wearing Armani, because Dennis's relationship with clothing is the relationship of a man who believes fabric becomes luxury through proximity to his body.
"The welfare system," Dennis announces, "is a goldmine. Free money. Free food. Free LIFESTYLE. And nobody is taking advantage of it the way we could."
Dee, beside him in an outfit that costs less than Griffin's bar tab at Ray's: "We're not taking advantage. We're experiencing. It's social research."
"It's social research that pays us to not work, Dee. That's the BEST kind of research."
The letter forms above Dennis's head. Griffin reads it with a peripheral glance while he dries a pint glass.
C
[SCHEME DISASTER RATING: C — CALAMITY. MODERATE SOCIAL DESTRUCTION. VEHICLE DAMAGE: HIGH PROBABILITY (DEE). FINANCIAL CONSEQUENCES: MODERATE (SYSTEM ABUSE). FRANK MODIFIER: PASSIVE (NOT DIRECTLY INVOLVED).]
C-tier. Frank's modifier is listed as passive — he's not funding this one, but his presence in the ecosystem means the Gang takes bigger swings even when Frank isn't in the room. The specific notation about vehicle damage makes Griffin's mouth twitch. Dee's car. The show destroyed that car with the relentless consistency of a universe that uses Dee's possessions as punchlines.
Griffin excuses himself to the bathroom. Locks the stall. Pulls out the flip phone.
Text to Sal: "Bet 1. Dennis and Dee welfare scheme. Property or vehicle damage within 72 hours. $50."
Thirty seconds pass. Sal's reply: "Welfare scheme? These people. Ill take it. 72 hrs property/vehicle dmg. $50. Prove it."
Griffin pockets the phone. Flushes for cover. Returns to the bar.
The scheme unfolds across four days. Dennis and Dee discover that welfare provides less than their bar income. Dennis discovers that the welfare office is staffed by people immune to his charm, which is a category of person Dennis doesn't believe exists and processes with the confusion of a man encountering a species he wasn't told about. Dee discovers that the bus system is unreliable, the food stamps don't cover sushi, and the experience of being poor is, in fact, poor.
Griffin pours drinks and watches the C hold steady.
The car dies on Thursday.
Not dramatically — Dee's car doesn't explode or crash or get stolen. The transmission gives out on Broad Street during a February cold snap, because Dee's car has been dying by inches for months and this scheme pushed it past the threshold of neglect. Dee stands on the sidewalk at 3 PM in the cold and calls Dennis, who doesn't answer because Dennis is at the welfare office arguing about supplemental benefits.
Griffin hears about it that evening when Dee comes into the bar — walking, because the car is still on Broad Street and the tow truck won't come until morning — and delivers a monologue about the injustice of a universe that punishes her for trying to understand the working class.
"My car is DEAD, Dennis. My actual car."
"We can claim it on the welfare—"
"You can't claim CAR DEATH on welfare."
"You can if you frame it correctly."
Griffin waits until closing. Takes out the flip phone. The walk to the car is twelve blocks — he goes because Sal wants proof and proof means documentation. Dee's Pontiac sits on the shoulder of Broad Street with its hazard lights dead because the battery died with the transmission. Griffin takes a photo with the flip phone's terrible camera — blurry, dark, barely legible, but identifiable as a car that isn't going anywhere.
Text to Sal: "Bet 1 proof. Attached photo. Dee Reynolds' car, dead on Broad St. 58 hours from scheme start."
Sal's reply, eleven minutes later: "You're 1 for 1. Lucky guess. Come collect Wed."
Griffin collects on Wednesday. Ninety dollars — fifty returned, forty profit. Sal counts the bills from a roll he keeps in his jacket and hands them over without ceremony.
"One," Sal says. "Two more."
The forty dollars sits in Griffin's wallet like a different substance than the bills around it. The bartender tips are earned through labor — pouring, cleaning, enduring. This forty was earned through knowledge. Through watching someone fail and knowing they'd fail and positioning himself to profit from the failure before it happened.
COMPLICITY: 7%
Seven percent. The lowest the meter has read during an active scheme since the CPS initialized. Griffin wasn't in the room for the car death. Wasn't involved in the welfare application. Wasn't present for any of the escalation. He poured drinks and sent texts and walked twelve blocks to photograph a dead car and collected forty dollars for the privilege.
The system says I'm barely involved. Seven percent. The math says I watched someone's car die and made money from it. Seven percent doesn't feel like seven percent.
He buys two coffees on the way home. One for himself, one for the Waitress — it's Tuesday, their day, and he hasn't been to the coffee shop in three weeks because the bookie search and the Frank adjustment ate his free time. She's behind the counter and her expression when he walks in is the specific mix of relief and reproach that people use on friends who've been absent without explanation.
"Three weeks," she says.
"I know. I'm sorry. Things got—"
"Complicated?"
"Busy. Complicated implies interesting."
"And busy implies boring."
"Busy implies I forgot to eat lunch for three days in a row and my apartment smells like a space heater that's been running since October."
She takes the coffee he offers — the second one, the one he bought for her from a bodega two blocks away because bringing a coffee shop employee a coffee from a different establishment is either thoughtful or insulting and Griffin decided to risk it.
"You brought me bodega coffee."
"Neutral territory."
She looks at the cup. Looks at him. Sips it. Her face does the thing faces do when they encounter coffee that costs a dollar and tastes like it.
"It's terrible."
"It's a gesture."
"It's a terrible gesture." But she's almost smiling, the way she almost smiled the first time they talked, the muscles fighting the expression like it's a confession. "Tuesday?"
"Tuesday. From now on. I promise."
"Don't promise. Just show up."
He shows up.
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes.
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!