Chapter 15: The One with Mrs. Bing
The story, as Monica told it, required some setup.
She and Phoebe had been walking down Columbus Avenue on a Tuesday morning — no particular agenda, the kind of walk that happens when two people are between things and the weather is decent enough to be outside. The conversation had been about something else entirely when Monica had, entirely involuntarily, whistled.
"It was involuntary," Monica said, to the group, with the dignity of a woman owning something she wasn't entirely comfortable with.
"It was not involuntary," Phoebe said. "You saw him and you whistled. It was cause and effect."
"It was a reflex," Monica said.
"A reflex you've been developing since approximately 1987," Ethan said.
"The point," Monica said, "is what happened next."
What happened next was that the man in question — who was, by all accounts, genuinely worth the involuntary reflex — had turned at the sound, stepped off the curb at exactly the wrong moment, and made contact with the front quarter-panel of a cab that was moving at the specific speed cabs moved on Columbus Avenue, which was too fast for pedestrian error but slow enough that the outcome was a hard fall rather than a catastrophe.
He was fine. That was established quickly. But he was also briefly unconscious, and then confused, and Monica and Phoebe had stayed with him until the ambulance came and then, because they were Monica and Phoebe, had gone to the hospital and waited.
"We were there for two hours," Phoebe said.
"Two and a half," Monica said.
"And when he woke up?" Rachel asked.
Monica and Phoebe exchanged the look of two people sharing a specific memory.
"He was very polite," Phoebe said.
"Very polite," Monica confirmed.
"He said thank you for staying, and that it was very kind, and that he hoped we hadn't been too inconvenienced."
"And then he said he didn't know us," Monica said. "Which — he didn't. That's factually correct. It just landed—"
"Like a whole bucket of something cold," Phoebe said.
"Exactly like that," Monica said.
The table absorbed this for a moment.
"But he's okay," Ross said.
"He's fine," Monica said. "Mild concussion, no lasting damage."
"Is he — I mean, is there a—" Joey began.
"He gave Phoebe his number," Monica said.
Everyone looked at Phoebe.
"He said I had a very calming presence," Phoebe said, with the serene acceptance of someone receiving information about themselves that they already knew. "He called it grounding."
"He got hit by a cab and came out of it with Phoebe's number," Chandler said slowly. "That is objectively the most successful cab accident in the history of New York."
"Don't call it a success," Monica said.
"I'm calling it a success for him," Chandler said. "The cab situation itself was clearly not ideal."
"His name is Paul," Phoebe said. "He's a physicist. He studies—" She paused, consulting some internal note. "Something with particles."
"Particle physics," Ethan said.
"That," Phoebe said. "He explained it in the ambulance and it was very interesting even though I understood approximately none of it."
"Are you going to call him?" Rachel asked.
"He's going to call me," Phoebe said. "He said so very specifically. He said: I'm going to call you. And he looked like he meant it."
"He might not remember," Joey said. "Concussion."
"He'll remember," Phoebe said, with the certainty she reserved for things she actually knew. "He has a very clear energy about follow-through."
The television had been on in the background through all of this — Monica's, later that evening, everyone having migrated there in the post-dinner way. Joey had the remote and was navigating with the particular inefficiency of someone who stopped on every channel for five seconds to assess it before moving on.
He stopped.
On screen, in the brightly lit set of a late-night talk show, a woman in her fifties was settling into the guest chair with the comfortable authority of someone who had been in this situation many times and found it agreeable. She had dark hair, excellent posture, and the expression of a woman who had decided a long time ago to find her own life genuinely entertaining and had not reconsidered.
The chyron at the bottom of the screen read: Nora Bing — Author, "Loving and Leaving: A Modern Woman's Guide to Getting What She Wants."
Chandler, who had been reaching for his coffee, stopped reaching.
"We don't need to watch this," he said.
"That's your mom," Joey said.
"I'm aware," Chandler said. "We still don't need to—"
"Chandler," Rachel said, "I love your mom's books."
Chandler looked at her.
"I'm serious," Rachel said. "I've read three of them. The one about the divorce, and the one about — I don't want to say in front of you, it'll be weird — and the new one. She's a great writer."
"She's a first-rate writer," Ross confirmed, from the armchair.
"She's my mother," Chandler said, in the tone of someone explaining why a thing that was objectively true was also deeply uncomfortable. "You're not supposed to read your mother's books. They're—" He gestured vaguely at a space that communicated things I cannot fully articulate but deeply feel.
"They're very honest," Rachel said.
"They're extremely honest," Chandler said. "That's the problem."
On screen, the host was asking Nora Bing about her process. She was answering with the specific ease of someone who had given this answer many times and had refined it into something that was still true but also very clean.
"Do you draw from personal experience?" the host asked.
Nora Bing smiled the smile of a woman who found this question slightly beneath her but was willing to engage with it. "Darling, I draw from everything. My marriages. My travels. My relationships. My son." She paused. "He's in New York. Living with his best friend, as young men do. He'll be fine."
"She's talking about you," Joey said, to Chandler.
"I know she's talking about me," Chandler said.
"She said you'll be fine," Joey said. "That's nice."
"Joey."
"I'm just saying."
The host leaned forward. "Tell us about the new book. There are some scenes that have been described as—"
"Progressive," Nora Bing said, before the host could finish. "I prefer progressive. The material is very honest about female desire and self-determination, which apparently some people find surprising in a woman my age, which is itself a statement about society worth examining." She uncrossed and recrossed her legs. "I've always believed that a woman who knows what she wants and goes after it is—" She paused. "Aspirational."
"Inspiring," Rachel said, watching the screen.
"Terrifying," Chandler said.
"Both can be true," Ethan said.
"Did I ask you?" Chandler said.
"You did not," Ethan said agreeably.
On screen, Nora Bing mentioned, in the specific offhand way of someone dropping information they had calculated the effect of: "I'll be in New York tomorrow, actually. Seeing my son and his friends. A dinner. We do this periodically."
The host: "And how is that? Dinner with the son of Nora Bing?"
Nora Bing: "He survives it. That's the best thing I can say."
Chandler pointed at the screen. "That," he said. "That right there. That is the sentence that explains my entire personality."
"We're going to dinner tomorrow," Monica said, pulling out the reservation confirmation she had clearly been holding. "Eight o'clock. Aurelio's. I made the reservation last week when she called."
"You made the reservation," Chandler said. "Already."
"Someone had to," Monica said.
Chandler looked around the room — everyone with the expressions of people who had decided they were going to dinner and were not particularly open to counterarguments.
"Fine," he said. "But I want the record to show that I had nothing to do with the TV appearance."
"Noted," Ethan said.
Aurelio's was the kind of restaurant that had made a decision about itself and committed to it — good lighting, good wine list, tables that were far enough apart for actual conversation, the kind of place where the food was excellent and the occasion of being there felt proportionate to that. Monica had chosen well, which was Monica's default.
Nora Bing was already at the table when they arrived.
She looked, in person, exactly like herself — which was its own thing, because her public persona was sufficiently specific that encountering it directly required a moment of adjustment. She was dressed in a way that communicated that she had opinions about herself and they were positive, and she looked at the approaching group with the expression of a woman assembling information quickly.
"Chandler," she said, standing, and pulled him into a hug that he accepted with the practiced ease of someone who had been accepting this particular hug his whole life.
"Hi, Mom," he said.
"You look tired," she said.
"I'm fine," he said.
"You look tired," she said again, but warmly, and let him go and turned to the group.
Introductions went around. Nora Bing had the gift of making each person feel like the introduction was specifically interesting to her, which was either genuine or the result of decades of practice, and possibly both.
Rachel, when her turn came, visibly overcame the impulse to say something fangirl-adjacent, and instead said: "I've read your last three books," with the contained energy of someone managing enthusiasm they had decided to manage.
Nora Bing looked at her with real attention. "Which was your favorite?"
"Between Tuesdays," Rachel said, without hesitating. "The main character's relationship with her own ambition. I read it right after I — after a pretty significant life change. It landed differently than I expected."
Nora Bing studied her for a moment. "You should come find me after dinner," she said. "I want to hear about the life change."
Rachel looked slightly surprised, then pleased. "Okay," she said.
When it was Ethan's turn, Chandler, with the specific expression of a man making a preemptive move: "Mom, Ethan's a screenwriter. In addition to being a PhD student. He just finished his first script."
"Did he." Nora Bing turned to Ethan with the focused interest of someone who had been given genuinely interesting information. "What's the project?"
"Time travel," Ethan said. "But the philosophical kind rather than the mechanical kind. The story folds back on itself — the protagonist is the cause of their own existence. Every choice in the film is also a consequence."
Nora Bing was quiet for a moment, in the way of someone actually thinking rather than waiting to respond. "Who's the audience for that?" she said. Not a challenge — a genuine question.
"Anyone who's ever made a decision they couldn't fully explain," Ethan said. "And then found out later that the decision was more inevitable than it seemed."
She looked at him. "You've thought about this."
"For a while," he said.
"Do you have representation?"
"Not yet."
She picked up her wine glass. "We'll talk," she said, which landed in the space between an offer and a certainty, and Ethan filed it away.
Chandler, two seats over, had the expression of a man watching two worlds interact in a way he hadn't fully anticipated.
The dinner was, by any measure, excellent — Monica and Nora Bing had discovered a shared opinion about risotto that launched a twenty-minute conversation neither of them needed to have but both clearly enjoyed. Joey had somehow gotten Nora to explain the premise of her new book and was listening with more focused attention than he usually brought to things that didn't involve food or acting. Ross and Phoebe were in a side conversation about particle physics, specifically what Phoebe had retained from Paul the physicist's ambulance explanation, which was impressionistic but enthusiastic.
Rachel and Nora had indeed found their after-dinner conversation — they'd migrated slightly apart from the group, heads together over the dessert menu, the conversation doing the thing where it was clearly about something real rather than something social.
Chandler sat next to Ethan and watched this for a moment.
"She likes your friends," Ethan said.
"She likes everyone," Chandler said. "That's its own thing."
"It's not a bad thing."
"No," Chandler said. "It's just — she turns it on very completely. It's like being in the sun. It's great and then you realize you've been in it for a while and you need some shade."
Ethan nodded. "What was it like growing up with that?"
Chandler thought about it with the rare seriousness he brought to things that actually required it. "Like being a supporting character in someone else's story," he said. "But a supporting character who was genuinely loved. Both of those things, at the same time."
Ethan looked at him.
"She means well," Chandler said. "She always has. It's just—" He paused. "The meaning well and the execution are two different departments, and they don't always coordinate."
"That's true of most people," Ethan said.
"Most people don't write about their kids' puberty in nationally distributed paperbacks," Chandler said.
"That's fair," Ethan said. "That's a specific situation."
Nora appeared at Ethan's elbow with the timing of someone who had been nearby for slightly longer than he'd realized. She had the quality of moving through spaces quietly when she chose to, which was at odds with her public presence and probably deliberate.
"Walk with me to the coat check," she said to Ethan.
It wasn't a question, which was fine — Ethan had clocked that about her within the first twenty minutes of dinner.
They walked.
At the coat check, while the attendant located the ticket, Nora turned to him with the focused attention she'd deployed at the table.
"The script," she said. "I wasn't being polite at dinner."
"I didn't think you were," Ethan said.
"I know people at Warner Brothers who are looking for original material," she said. "Not looking in the way that everyone in this industry is always vaguely looking. Looking in the way where they have a specific gap they're trying to fill and the right project would go quickly." She reached into her bag and produced a card, which she pressed into his hand with the specific efficiency of someone who had done this before and knew what the gesture was worth. "Call me next week. Bring the script."
Ethan looked at the card. Nora Bing, with a New York number and a Los Angeles number and an email address that suggested she was slightly ahead of most people her age on that front.
"Thank you," he said.
"Don't thank me," she said. "If it's good, you'll thank the script. If it's not good, I'll tell you, and you'll thank me for that instead." She looked at him with the assessing expression she'd had since the introduction. "It's good, isn't it."
"I think so," he said.
"You know so," she said. "People who only think it's good don't talk about it the way you do." She took her coat from the attendant. "Call me next week."
She walked back toward the table, and Ethan stood at the coat check for a moment with the card in his hand and the particular feeling of a door that had just opened in a wall he'd known was there but hadn't yet found the door in.
He put the card in his inside jacket pocket and went back to the table.
Chandler looked at him. "What did she say?"
"She wants to read the script," Ethan said.
Chandler processed this. "Of course she does," he said, without any particular edge — just the acceptance of a man who had grown up understanding that his mother operated in a way that made certain things happen and that this was simply true. "Is that good?"
"I think it's very good," Ethan said.
"Then good," Chandler said, and picked up his wine glass. "She does have good taste. I'll give her that."
"She gave me the Warner Brothers contact," Ethan said.
Chandler looked at him. "Warner Brothers."
"Warner Brothers," Ethan confirmed.
Chandler was quiet for a moment. Then he raised his glass slightly. "To my mother," he said, "who is a lot, and occasionally very useful."
Ethan raised his glass.
"To Nora Bing," he said.
Later, walking back through the January night — cold and clear, the kind of night where the city looked like it had been cleaned — Chandler fell into step beside Ethan while the others moved ahead.
"The 'supporting character in someone else's story' thing," Chandler said. "That I said at dinner."
"Yeah," Ethan said.
"I don't know where that came from," Chandler said. "I don't usually—" He stopped. "I don't usually say things like that."
"I know," Ethan said.
"Is that—" Chandler paused. "Is that how it reads? From outside?"
Ethan looked at him. "I think you've been the main character of your story for a while," he said. "You've just been narrating it like a supporting role. Those aren't the same thing."
Chandler walked a few steps without responding.
"That's going to stay with me," he said finally.
"Good," Ethan said. "It should."
Ahead of them, Monica was explaining something to Joey with her hands, and Phoebe was humming what was probably the beginning of a new song, and Rachel was still holding the piece of paper Nora Bing had written something on for her at dinner, looking at it with the expression of someone who had been given something they weren't sure what to do with yet but intended to find out.
The city moved around them, cold and lit and going wherever it was going.
Ethan put his hands in his pockets and kept walking.
Next: The Warner Brothers call. Joey books Days of Our Lives and reacts with appropriate enormity. Phoebe calls Paul the physicist, who answers on the first ring. Rachel does something with the piece of paper Nora Bing gave her.
[500 Power Stones → +1 Bonus Chapter]
[10 Reviews → +1 Bonus Chapter]
Enjoyed the chapter? A review helps a lot.
P1treon: Soulforger (20+advance chapters)