Three days had passed since Tauriel's evening visit to his chambers.
They'd spoken for hours that first night—patrol routes, corruption patterns, the political currents flowing beneath the court's surface. She'd been careful, professional, never quite asking the questions her eyes kept forming. And Legolas had been equally careful, offering truths wrapped in careful omissions, building something that might become trust.
Now he stood at the edge of actively corrupted Mirkwood, about to test whether his growing abilities could do more than light empty glades.
The boundary was invisible to normal sight but unmistakable to his new perception. The forest changed character in a single step—healthy trees giving way to twisted forms whose bark wept black ichor, whose leaves curled inward like fists. The air grew thick, heavy with a sweetness that had nothing to do with flowers.
Legolas crossed the line.
His magical senses—still raw, still developing—translated what the films had never shown. The corruption wasn't simple decay. It was architecture. Morgul-sorcery embedded in the soil itself, spreading through root systems, climbing up trunk and branch to canopy. Every infected tree became a node in a network he could almost see, dark lines connecting them like a web of poisoned nerves.
And all of it led south. To Dol Guldur. To the Necromancer who wasn't a necromancer at all.
He walked deeper. Each step required effort now—not physical, but spiritual. The wrongness pressed against him, testing boundaries he hadn't known existed. His light-echoes flickered in response, defensive reactions he couldn't quite control.
This is what we're fighting, he thought. This is what's been growing for centuries while the Elves retreated and hoped it would stop.
It wouldn't stop. He knew that from memory that didn't belong to this world. Sauron's corruption was patient and inexorable, and without intervention, it would consume everything green in Mirkwood long before the Ring was found.
The whisper came without warning.
You are new.
Legolas froze. The voice—if it could be called a voice—came from everywhere and nowhere, vibrating through the corruption network itself. Not words exactly, but meaning, pressed directly into his awareness.
You are... unwritten.
"Who speaks?" The question left his lips before wisdom could stop it.
The darkness rippled. Something turned its attention toward him—not Sauron, not directly, but a fragment. An awareness embedded in the corruption itself, left to monitor and report.
We have watched this forest for centuries. We know every song the Elves sing, every light they kindle, every futile attempt to push back what cannot be stopped.
The presence circled him. Legolas couldn't see it, couldn't locate it, but he could feel it examining him from angles that shouldn't exist.
But you... your song is new. Your light is borrowed. Your soul carries no imprint of this world's making.
His blood went cold.
What are you?
"I am Legolas Greenleaf," he said, forcing steadiness into his voice. "Prince of the Woodland Realm."
The laughter that followed had no sound, but it echoed through his bones.
You wear his shape. You speak with his voice. But your spirit is... unmarked. Unwritten in the Music that shapes all things.
The presence pressed closer. The corruption around him intensified, trees groaning as dark sap swelled in their wounds.
We have techniques your borrowed Elves have forgotten. Knowledge they never possessed. The secrets of shaping flesh and binding spirit, the arts Morgoth taught in ages past.
Legolas's Universal Magic Compatibility stirred in recognition. The horror of it hit him like a physical blow—his ability to absorb any magical tradition didn't distinguish between light and dark. The Shadow's corruption was a learnable skill set, and part of him wanted to understand it.
We could teach you, the presence whispered. What you are... you could become something unprecedented. Neither Elf nor Man nor Maia. Something new. Something powerful beyond measure.
His hands had started to shake. Not from fear—from temptation.
The knowledge was right there. Centuries of accumulated power, techniques that could reshape reality itself. He could feel it at the edge of his perception, waiting to be claimed. All he had to do was reach...
"No."
The word came out hoarse, forced through a throat that didn't want to cooperate.
Refusal? But you want it. We can feel the hunger in you—the need to understand, to collect, to grow strong enough to face what's coming. Why deny yourself?
"Because I've seen where it leads." Legolas stepped backward, putting distance between himself and the thickest corruption. "I know what you become when you drink from that well."
The presence pulsed with something that might have been amusement.
You speak of knowledge you should not possess. Futures unseen by Elvish eyes. Perhaps you are more interesting than we realized.
Legolas turned and ran.
Not gracefully—not with the fluid motion his borrowed body should have managed. He crashed through undergrowth, stumbled over roots that seemed to reach for his ankles, fought his way toward the boundary he could feel rather than see.
The whisper followed him, carried on wind that moved wrong.
We will remember you, unwritten one. When you tire of borrowed light and borrowed lies, we will still be here. The door remains open.
He burst across the boundary and kept running.
The clean air hit his lungs like cold water. The pressure lifted. The whisper faded, though not entirely—an echo remained at the edge of his awareness, a reminder that something had seen him. Something had understood what he was.
Legolas collapsed at the base of an uncorrupted tree. His hands shook against the grass. His breath came in ragged gasps that his Elvish body shouldn't require.
It offered to teach me.
The thought wouldn't stop repeating. The Shadow had looked at his soul and seen potential—a vessel capable of holding its secrets, learning its arts. And for one terrible moment, he'd considered it.
That was the real horror. Not the corruption or the whisper or the intelligence behind them. The horror was how close he'd come to reaching for power he knew would destroy him.
His hands wouldn't stop trembling.
What am I becoming?
The sun had shifted by the time Legolas could stand without his legs threatening to fold. He brushed dirt from his clothes with mechanical precision, forcing the borrowed body through familiar motions while his mind raced.
The Shadow knew something was wrong with him. Not everything—it had called him "unwritten," sensing his lack of connection to Arda's Music rather than understanding the transmigration itself. But that knowledge was dangerous enough.
It would report. Maybe not to Sauron directly—the Necromancer had larger concerns than one anomalous Elf—but the information would filter into the corruption's awareness. The darkness would be watching him now.
Which meant he had to act before it could adapt.
Legolas looked back at the corrupted zone. Something in the twisted trees looked back—he could feel it, that sense of being observed that had followed him out of the darkness.
Tomorrow, he would bring a proposal to the King. Offense before defense. Show Thranduil that his changed son could be an asset rather than a threat.
And pray the Shadow's attention didn't turn lethal before he was ready to fight it.
Note:
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.