The patrol moved through Mirkwood's healthier sections with the silent efficiency that centuries of practice had perfected. Tauriel led, her newly-earned captain's insignia glinting when stray light caught the metal. Legolas followed three paces behind, close enough to observe, distant enough to let her command without interference.
Three days had passed since the messenger's arrival. Three days of preparation, intelligence gathering, and careful positioning. The Dwarves had been tracked since crossing the forest's eastern boundary, their progress slower than expected—understandable, given that the corruption grew thicker the deeper one traveled.
Now they were close.
"Movement ahead," Tauriel signaled, her hand cutting through the air in patrol-speak. "Multiple heat signatures. Ground-level."
Legolas scaled the nearest tree with the fluid grace his borrowed body had finally begun to provide reliably. The Glorfindel training was integrating, slowly—he still couldn't execute the complex combat forms, but the climbing and positioning came easier now.
From the branches, he had a clear view of the forest floor below.
Thirteen Dwarves moved in a rough column, their heavy boots announcing their presence to anything with ears to hear. They were tired, filthy, and clearly lost—the enchanted paths of Mirkwood had done their work, leading the company in circles until their supplies ran thin.
And there, at the column's center, was a figure too small to be a Dwarf.
Bilbo.
The name rose from memories that didn't belong to this world. Bilbo Baggins, hobbit of the Shire, currently in possession of a ring he didn't understand. The Ring. The One Ring, picked up in Gollum's cave, tucked away in a pocket like any ordinary trinket.
The weight of that knowledge pressed against Legolas's skull.
He could act. Could descend right now, demand the Ring's surrender, explain what it was and what it would become. He could change everything—prevent the War of the Ring before it began, save countless lives that would be lost in the decades to come.
And in doing so, destroy every thread of fate he understood.
The Ring had to reach Frodo. Frodo had to carry it to Mount Doom. Gandalf had to fall and rise again. The Fellowship had to break and reform and triumph through the most unlikely of circumstances.
Change too much, and none of it would happen. The Ring would pass to someone else—someone without a hobbit's resistance to its corruption. Someone who would fall faster, harder, in ways that couldn't be predicted.
The script exists for reasons, Legolas reminded himself. The words had become a kind of mantra over the past weeks. Not all of them bad.
"My prince?" Tauriel's voice came from below, questioning his stillness.
"Thirteen Dwarves," Legolas reported, descending. "One... smaller figure. Not a Dwarf—a Halfling, perhaps. They're lost, exhausted, and heading toward the Spider territories."
"Should we intercept?"
The question was practical, devoid of the political weight it carried. Tauriel was thinking tactically—rescue these travelers before the spiders found them—while Legolas was thinking in terms of timelines and fate.
"Not yet." He landed beside her, keeping his voice neutral. "Let them proceed further into the realm. When they reach the deeper corruption, we can make contact and escort them to the palace."
Tauriel's expression shifted slightly—confusion at the delay. "They may not survive the Spider territories unassisted."
"They will." The certainty in his voice surprised even him. "These are not ordinary travelers. The leader—the one in front, with the dark hair and royal bearing—is Thorin Oakenshield. Heir to Erebor. They're on a quest the Dwarves have been planning for years."
"Erebor." Tauriel's eyes widened with recognition. "The dragon. They mean to reclaim the mountain."
"Yes."
The implications unfolded in Tauriel's tactical mind. Legolas could see her processing: Smaug the Terrible, gold beyond counting, ancient grudges between Elves and Dwarves, and the political complications that would arise from interfering with such a quest.
"The King will want to know."
"The King will know when they reach our halls." Legolas gestured for the patrol to spread out, taking shadowing positions. "For now, we watch. We protect them from the worst threats without revealing ourselves. And when the time comes, we escort them to my father."
"Protect them?" One of the other guards—Maethor, the veteran skeptic—looked doubtful. "They're Dwarves, my prince. Trespassing on our lands. The King's standing orders—"
"Will be followed once they're in custody. But corpses make poor prisoners, and the spiders have been aggressive since our last cleansing." Legolas met the old warrior's eyes steadily. "We shadow. We intervene only if their lives are truly threatened. Understood?"
The guards exchanged glances but nodded. Tauriel's expression held something he couldn't quite read—curiosity, perhaps, or the dawning recognition that the prince she'd begun to trust was playing a longer game than anyone realized.
They moved through the canopy, keeping pace with the Dwarven company below. Legolas found a position that gave him a clear view of the small figure in their midst.
Bilbo walked with the exhausted determination of someone who'd committed to something beyond his understanding. His hobbit-clothes were travel-stained, his curly hair a mess of tangles and twigs. He looked completely out of place among the stocky, martial Dwarves.
And in his pocket, invisible to any eye but the darkest, rested the most dangerous artifact in Middle-earth.
You have no idea what you're carrying, Legolas thought. None of you do. And when you finally understand, it will nearly destroy everything.
The Dwarves made camp as darkness fell, their fire a beacon in the corrupted forest. Legolas watched from the branches above, close enough to hear fragments of conversation—complaints about the food, arguments about direction, the gruff reassurances Thorin offered to keep morale from collapsing entirely.
This was history unfolding. Stories he'd read as a child in another life, another world, playing out before Elvish eyes that shouldn't exist.
The dragon would die. The battle would rage. Thorin would fall to gold-sickness and emerge only in death, and Bilbo would carry a Ring home without understanding what it would one day cost the world.
And Legolas could do nothing but watch.
Small adjustments, he reminded himself. Not derailment.
When Thranduil inevitably captured these Dwarves—and he would; the enchanted paths led only to the palace eventually—Legolas could influence their treatment. Could advocate for shorter imprisonment, better conditions. Could plant seeds of cooperation that might matter in the battles to come.
The Battle of Five Armies was approaching. Elves, Dwarves, and Men would fight side by side against Orcs and worse. The alliances forged there would echo through the War of the Ring.
That's where I can make a difference, Legolas thought. Not by stopping the story, but by shaping how it's told.
The night deepened around him. Below, the Dwarves slept while one stood watch, and somewhere in their midst, a hobbit dreamed of home, a golden ring tucked safely in his pocket.
Note:
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.