Cherreads

Chapter 8 - bwst friends

ROOM 7

Chapter Seven: The Best Friends (Part Two)

---

Three weeks had passed since the handhold on the rooftop.

Three weeks of Jay and Keifer being something that wasn't quite enemies and wasn't quite anything else. Three weeks of stolen glances and morning coffee and a book that Jay had read three times already.

Three weeks of Lyra and Alex being absolutely, insufferably, impossibly normal.

And everyone in Room 7 was losing their minds.

---

Part One: The Morning Ritual

It started every morning at exactly 7:15 AM.

Alex would wake up. He'd stretch. He'd put on his headphones. He'd walk to the coffee machine and make exactly one cup— black, no sugar, the way Lyra liked it.

Then he'd walk to Lyra's bed.

Lyra would be awake— she was always awake, waiting— but she'd pretend to be sleeping. Her eyes would be closed. Her breathing would be soft. She'd look peaceful and quiet and nothing like the chaos demon she became when she was actually conscious.

Alex would set the coffee on her nightstand.

He'd stand there for a moment.

Just a moment.

Then he'd walk away.

Every morning. The same ritual. The same coffee. The same pause.

And every morning, everyone in Room 7 watched it happen like it was the most important event of the day.

This morning was no different.

Alex set the coffee down. He paused. He looked at Lyra's face— soft in sleep, her hair spread across the pillow, her lips slightly parted.

He reached out. His hand hovered near her cheek.

Then he pulled back.

He walked away.

Lyra's eyes opened the second he turned.

She stared at the ceiling.

She didn't reach for the coffee.

Not until he was gone.

---

Part Two: The Audience

Yuri was the first to break.

"THREE WEEKS!" he shouted, throwing his pillow across the room. "THREE WEEKS OF THIS!"

Alex looked up from his bed. "Of what?"

"OF YOU MAKING HER COFFEE! OF YOU STANDING THERE LIKE A LOVE-SICK PUPPY! OF YOU ALMOST TOUCHING HER FACE AND THEN NOT!"

"I don't almost touch her face."

"YOUR HAND WAS TWO INCHES FROM HER CHEEK!"

"I was checking if she was breathing."

"SHE WAS BREATHING! PEOPLE BREATHE WHEN THEY SLEEP!"

"Sometimes people stop breathing when they sleep. It's called sleep apnea."

"LYRA DOESN'T HAVE SLEEP APNEA!"

"You don't know that."

"I KNOW THAT BECAUSE I'VE LIVED WITH HER FOR THREE MONTHS AND SHE DOESN'T SNORE!"

"Not snoring doesn't mean no sleep apnea."

"ALEX!"

"What?"

Yuri grabbed his own hair. "I CAN'T DO THIS. I CAN'T WATCH THIS EVERY MORNING. IT'S LIKE WATCHING TWO PEOPLE DROWN IN SLOW MOTION WHILE REFUSING TO GRAB THE LIFE RAFT."

"What life raft?"

"EACH OTHER! YOU'RE THE LIFE RAFT FOR EACH OTHER!"

Alex's ears turned red. "We're best friends. Best friends make coffee for each other."

"BEST FRIENDS DON'T STAND THERE STARING AT EACH OTHER'S FACES FOR THIRTY SECONDS!"

"It was five seconds."

"FREYA COUNTED! IT WAS TWENTY-THREE SECONDS!"

Freya held up her phone. "Twenty-three point five. I have video evidence."

Alex stared at her. "You've been timing me?"

"I've been documenting. There's a difference."

"There's literally no difference."

"Documenting is scientific. Timing is obsessive. I'm being scientific."

Alex buried his face in his hands.

Lyra, who had been sitting up in bed pretending to read, finally spoke. "Can everyone please leave Alex alone? He makes me coffee because I'm his best friend. That's what best friends do."

"You don't make him coffee," Mica said quietly.

Lyra's mouth opened. Closed.

"You don't make him coffee," Mica repeated. "He makes you coffee. Every morning. You've never once made him coffee."

"I— that's—" Lyra sputtered. "I don't know how he likes it!"

"He likes it with milk and one sugar. The same way he's liked it since you were twelve years old."

The room went silent.

Lyra stared at Mica. "How do you know that?"

"I pay attention."

"I pay attention too!"

"Do you?"

Lyra looked at Alex. Alex looked at the floor.

"I know how he likes his coffee," Lyra said quietly.

"Then why don't you make it?"

"Because—" She stopped. Swallowed. "Because if I make it, then it's a thing. Then it's not just best friends. Then it's something else. And we're best friends. That's all."

Alex looked up.

Lyra met his eyes. "We're best friends. Right, Alex?"

The room held its breath.

Alex's jaw tightened. "Right. Best friends."

"Best friends," Lyra repeated.

"Nothing more."

"Nothing more."

The silence was unbearable.

David, who had been watching the whole thing while eating a granola bar, said, "You know, I make coffee for everyone sometimes. Just because. It doesn't have to be a thing."

"THANK YOU, DAVID!" Lyra said.

"But I don't make it for the same person every morning at the same time. That's not just coffee. That's something."

"DAVID!"

"I'm just saying."

"You're supposed to be neutral!"

"I am neutral. Neutral doesn't mean blind."

Lyra grabbed her pillow and screamed into it.

Alex grabbed his headphones and put them on.

Everyone else exchanged looks that said this is going to take a while.

---

Part Three: The Study Session

Later that day, Jay found Lyra in the library.

She was sitting in the darkest corner, surrounded by textbooks she wasn't reading. Her highlighters were untouched. Her notebook was blank.

"You're not studying," Jay said, sitting down across from her.

"I'm thinking."

"About Alex?"

"About—" Lyra hesitated. "Yes."

"What about him?"

Lyra was quiet for a long moment. Then: "Do you think I'm being unfair?"

"Unfair how?"

"He makes me coffee every morning. Every single morning. And I just... let him. I don't say thank you. I don't acknowledge it. I just let him do this thing for me and pretend it doesn't mean anything."

"Does it mean something?"

Lyra's eyes flickered. "It means we're best friends. Best friends do things for each other."

Jay leaned forward. "Lyra."

"What?"

"Best friends don't stare at each other's faces for twenty-three seconds."

"Freya exaggerated. It was five seconds."

"Freya doesn't exaggerate. She documents."

"Well, she documented wrong."

"You're avoiding the question."

"What question?"

"Do you want it to mean something?"

Lyra's hands tightened around her coffee cup. Alex's coffee cup. The one he'd made for her this morning. Cold now. She was still holding it.

"I don't know what you're talking about."

"Lyra."

"JAY. Stop." Lyra's voice was sharp. "Alex is my best friend. He's been my best friend since I was five years old. He knows everything about me. He's the most important person in my life. And I'm not going to ruin that because a bunch of people in that room think every nice thing is a love confession."

"I'm not saying—"

"You're saying exactly what everyone else is saying. That we're in love. That we should be together. That we're idiots for pretending we're just friends." Lyra's voice cracked. "But we ARE just friends. That's what we've always been. That's what we'll always be. And I need everyone to stop trying to make it into something it's not."

Jay was quiet for a moment.

Then she said, "Okay."

Lyra blinked. "Okay?"

"Okay. You're just best friends. I believe you."

"You do?"

"I do." Jay reached across the table and took Lyra's hand. "But Lyra? If you ever change your mind about that? If you ever want it to be something more? That's okay too."

Lyra's eyes filled with tears. "I won't change my mind."

"Okay."

"I won't."

"Okay."

They sat in silence for a long time.

Lyra didn't let go of Jay's hand.

She also didn't let go of Alex's coffee cup.

---

Part Four: The Elevator

That evening, Alex found himself alone in the elevator with Keifer.

They stood in silence for a moment. Then Keifer said, "You love her."

Alex didn't pretend not to know who he was talking about. "She's my best friend."

"That's not what I asked."

"I know what you asked."

"So?"

Alex was quiet for a long moment. "So what if I do? It doesn't change anything. We're best friends. That's what works for us."

"Does it work?"

"It's worked for fifteen years."

"Fifteen years of pretending."

"It's not pretending." Alex's voice was tight. "She's my best friend. That's all she needs to be. That's all I need her to be."

Keifer looked at him. Really looked. "You're lying."

"I'm not."

"Your ears are red."

"I have a fever."

"It's December."

"Fevers happen in December."

Keifer laughed— soft and knowing. "You know, you sound exactly like Jay when she's pretending she doesn't care about me."

Alex didn't respond.

The elevator doors opened. They didn't get out.

"Look," Keifer said. "I'm not going to tell you what to do. I'm the last person who should be giving advice about this. But I will say this— pretending is exhausting. And fifteen years is a long time to be tired."

He walked out of the elevator.

Alex stood there for a long moment.

Then he pressed the button for the ground floor.

He needed air.

---

Part Five: The Movie Night

Friday night. Movie night in Room 7.

It was a tradition now. Every week, someone picked a movie. Everyone gathered in the common area. David made popcorn. Mica and Calix arranged blankets. Yuri complained about the selection. Freya documented everything.

Tonight, Lyra had picked the movie.

She picked a romance.

No one said anything. Everyone just looked at her.

"What?" she said. "It's a good movie."

"It's a romance," Yuri said.

"So?"

"You never pick romances."

"I'm picking one tonight. Do you have a problem with that?"

"No problem. No problem at all." Yuri settled into his seat with a grin. "This is going to be amazing."

The movie started.

Alex sat on one end of the couch. Lyra sat on the other end. There were three feet of space between them. Three feet of space that everyone in the room was staring at.

"Can everyone stop staring?" Lyra said.

"We're not staring," Mica said.

"You're all staring."

"We're watching the movie."

"The movie is over there. You're looking at me."

"You're very interesting to look at."

"MICA!"

Mica smiled sweetly and turned back to the screen.

The movie played. Two people fell in love on screen. They danced in the rain. They confessed their feelings. They kissed in slow motion.

Lyra's hands were in fists on her knees.

Alex's jaw was tight.

Three feet of space.

Neither of them moved.

At the climax of the movie— the big confession scene, the part where the hero finally says what he's been feeling the whole time— Lyra grabbed her blanket and stood up.

"I need air."

She walked to the rooftop.

The room was silent.

Alex stared at the door.

"She needs air," Yuri said. "On the rooftop. Where people confess things."

"She just needs air," Alex said.

"Alex."

"She just needs air."

"ALEX."

Alex stood up. He walked to the door. He stopped with his hand on the handle.

"If I go after her," he said quietly, "everyone's going to say it's something it's not."

"What is it?" Mica asked.

"It's me checking on my best friend. That's all."

"That's all?"

"That's all."

He opened the door and walked out.

---

Part Six: The Rooftop

She was standing at the edge, looking out at the city.

The same rooftop where Jay had chased Keifer. The same rooftop where hands were held and almost-confessions were made.

Lyra was hugging herself against the cold.

"You'll freeze," Alex said, walking up beside her.

"I needed air."

"There's air inside."

"Not the same air."

They stood in silence.

The city sparkled below them. The wind was cold. The sky was clear.

"I picked a romance," Lyra said.

"I noticed."

"I never pick romances."

"I noticed that too."

"Because people get weird about it. They see two best friends watching a romance and they think it means something."

Alex was quiet. "Does it?"

Lyra turned to look at him. "No. It's just a movie."

"It's just a movie."

"People make everything into something it's not."

"They do."

"You make me coffee every morning and everyone thinks it's a love confession."

"It's coffee."

"It's coffee."

"You drink it even when it's cold."

Lyra's breath caught. "I don't—"

"You drink it even when it's cold. You hold onto the cup for hours. I've seen you."

Lyra looked away. "It's a good cup."

"It's a paper cup."

"It's a very sturdy paper cup."

Alex laughed. It was a sad sound. "Lyra."

"What?"

"Why do you hold onto it?"

"Because—" She stopped. Swallowed. "Because you made it for me. Because it's the first thing I get from you every day. Because when I hold it, it feels like—"

She stopped again.

"Like what?" Alex asked.

Lyra shook her head. "Nothing. It feels like nothing. We're best friends. That's all."

"That's all."

"That's all we've ever been."

"That's all we'll ever be."

They said it together. Like a ritual. Like something they'd rehearsed a thousand times.

The wind blew.

Lyra shivered.

Alex took off his jacket and put it around her shoulders.

"Best friends do that," Lyra said.

"Best friends do that."

"Best friends stand on rooftops together."

"Best friends stand on rooftops together."

"Best friends don't confess things."

"Best friends don't confess things."

They stood in silence for a long moment.

Then Alex said, "I should go back inside."

"Okay."

"It's cold."

"It's cold."

"You have my jacket."

"I have your jacket."

He turned to leave.

Lyra grabbed his hand.

He stopped.

"Best friends hold hands," she said.

"Best friends hold hands."

"Sometimes."

"Sometimes."

She held on.

He held on.

Neither of them counted the seconds.

---

Part Seven: The Return

They walked back into Room 7 holding hands.

Everyone saw.

Everyone went absolutely insane.

Yuri literally fell off his chair. "OH MY GOD! OH MY GOD! THEY'RE HOLDING HANDS!"

"We can see that, Yuri," Mica said.

"BUT THEY'RE HOLDING HANDS!"

"Yes."

"IN PUBLIC!"

"Yes."

"AFTER TWENTY-THREE SECONDS ON THE ROOFTOP!"

"It was five seconds," Lyra said.

"FREYA COUNTED! IT WAS TWENTY-THREE!"

Freya held up her phone. "Twenty-three point five. I have video evidence."

"DELETE THAT!" Lyra shrieked.

"NEVER!"

Yuri grabbed Calix by the shoulders. "THIS IS THE GREATEST DAY OF MY LIFE!"

"You say that every week."

"THIS WEEK IT'S TRUE!"

Freya's camera was clicking nonstop. "The lighting on the rooftop was perfect. I got everything."

"You followed us?" Alex asked.

"I documented. There's a difference."

"FREYA!"

"ALEX!"

Care and Cole, who had been arguing about something academic, stopped mid-sentence to stare.

"Well," Care said.

"Well," Cole said.

"They're holding hands."

"They're holding hands."

"Does that mean they're finally—"

"No. It means they're best friends holding hands."

"That's not a thing."

"It's their thing."

David was the only one who didn't look surprised. He was sitting in his usual spot, eating popcorn, watching the chaos unfold.

"You knew," Jay said.

"I knew."

"How?"

David shrugged. "They've been holding hands in their own way since the first week. This is just the first time they're doing it in front of everyone."

Keifer walked up beside Jay. "So. They're holding hands."

"They're holding hands."

"But they're still just best friends."

"Apparently."

"For how long?"

Jay looked at him. "What do you mean?"

"I mean, how long can two people hold hands and stare at each other and make each other coffee every morning before it stops being 'just best friends'?"

"That's not our business."

"It's everyone's business. We live in a room with twelve people and no walls."

Jay laughed— soft and unexpected. "That's true."

Lyra, still holding Alex's hand, walked over to Jay. Her face was red from the cold and the teasing. "We're just best friends."

"I know," Jay said.

"We were cold. Best friends share jackets."

"Best friends share jackets."

"And best friends hold hands when it's cold."

"Best friends hold hands when it's cold."

Lyra squeezed her hand. "Thank you for not making it weird."

"You're welcome."

Yuri, from across the room, shouted, "IT'S ALREADY WEIRD! EVERYTHING ABOUT THIS IS WEIRD!"

"SHUT UP, YURI!"

"I WON'T SHUT UP! THIS IS THE WEIRDEST BEST FRIENDSHIP I'VE EVER SEEN!"

"THAT'S BECAUSE YOU'VE NEVER HAD A REAL BEST FRIEND!"

"I HAVE YURI!"

"YURI IS YOURSELF!"

"EXACTLY! I'M MY OWN BEST FRIEND!"

"That doesn't count!"

"IT COUNTS TO ME!"

Alex, still holding Lyra's hand, looked at her. "Should we let go?"

"No."

"Okay."

"Best friends don't have to let go just because people are watching."

"Best friends don't have to let go."

They didn't let go.

---

Part Eight: The Night

Later that night, long after everyone had gone to sleep, Jay lay in her bed and stared at the ceiling.

She could hear Keifer breathing from across the room. Two beds away. But in the silence, it felt like he was right next to her.

She liked that.

She didn't hate that.

"Hey, Mariano."

His voice was soft. Quiet. Just for her.

"Hey, Watson."

"Can't sleep?"

"No."

"Me neither."

Silence.

"Lyra and Alex held hands on the rooftop," she said.

"They did."

"And they came back saying they're just best friends."

"They did."

"Do you believe them?"

Keifer was quiet for a moment. Then: "I believe they believe it."

"That's not an answer."

"It's the only answer I have."

Jay rolled onto her side, facing his direction. "Do you think best friends can hold hands and make coffee every morning and stand on rooftops together and still just be best friends?"

"I think they can be whatever they want to be. That's the point of best friends. You get to decide."

"And if they decide wrong?"

"Then they figure it out later. Or they don't. Either way, it's their decision."

Jay smiled into her pillow. "You're surprisingly wise for someone who steals highlighters."

"I'm surprisingly wise for someone who's in love with a Mariano."

The words hung in the air.

Jay's heart stopped. "Keifer—"

"I said what I said." His voice was steady. "You don't have to say it back. You don't have to do anything with it. I'm just not going to pretend anymore. Not about that."

Silence.

"You love me?" Jay whispered.

"I've loved you since I was fourteen years old. Since the first family dinner. You wore a red dress. You spilled wine on my shirt. You apologized by calling me 'that Watson boy.' I've been yours ever since."

Jay's eyes filled with tears.

"Keifer."

"Mariano."

"I don't know what to say."

"Say nothing. Say 'I need more time.' Say 'I'm not ready.' Say whatever you need to say. I'm not going anywhere."

Jay stared at the ceiling.

Her heart was pounding.

Her hands were shaking.

"I'm scared," she said.

"I know."

"What if I ruin everything?"

"You won't."

"What if I'm not good at this?"

"Then we'll figure it out together."

"What if—"

"Jay." His voice was soft. "Stop trying to strategize. Stop trying to control it. Just let yourself feel something. Just for tonight."

She closed her eyes.

She let herself feel it.

"I'm not ready to say it back," she said.

"That's okay."

"But I'm not pretending anymore either."

"That's more than okay."

She reached out her hand.

Across the room, she saw his hand reach out too.

They didn't hold hands. They couldn't— there was too much space between their beds. But they reached.

And that was enough.

For now, that was enough.

---

Part Nine: The Morning After

Jay woke up to a text from Lyra.

Lyra: we held hands

Jay: I know. I was there.

Lyra: ON THE ROOFTOP

Jay: I wasn't on the rooftop.

Lyra: freya was

Lyra: she showed me the photos

Lyra: we were holding hands

Lyra: for a long time

Jay: Twenty-three seconds.

Lyra: IT WAS FIVE

Jay: Freya counted.

Lyra: FREYA IS A MENACE

Jay: She's a documentarian.

Lyra: SHE'S A MENACE WITH A CAMERA

Jay: So you held hands.

Lyra: we were cold

Jay: Best friends hold hands when they're cold.

Lyra: YES

Jay: Best friends also make coffee every morning.

Lyra: YES

Jay: And stand on rooftops together.

Lyra: YES

Jay: And stare at each other for twenty-three seconds.

Lyra: IT WAS FIVE

Jay: Freya counted.

Lyra: I'M BLOCKING FREYA

Jay: You won't.

Lyra: I WILL

Jay: You need her photos for the family archive.

Lyra: THERE IS NO FAMILY ARCHIVE

Jay: There is now. Your mom asked for copies.

Lyra: MY MOM KNOWS ABOUT THE ROOFTOP?

Jay: Your mom knows everything. She's in the group chat.

Lyra: THERE'S A GROUP CHAT?

Jay: There's always been a group chat.

Lyra: I'M GOING TO DIE

Jay: You're going to be fine.

Lyra: ARE WE GOING TO TALK ABOUT YOU AND KEIFER?

Jay: There's nothing to talk about.

Lyra: YOUR HAND WAS REACHING FOR HIS LAST NIGHT

Jay: I was stretching.

Lyra: AT 2 AM?

Jay: I have restless arm syndrome.

Lyra: THAT'S NOT A THING

Jay: It's a thing.

Lyra: JAY

Jay: LYRA

Lyra: I saw your face this morning

Lyra: you looked at him differently

Jay: I looked at him the same as always.

Lyra: no

Lyra: you looked at him like he was the sun

Lyra: like alex looks at me

Lyra: like i look at alex

Lyra: when we think no one's watching

Jay stared at her phone.

She didn't respond.

Across the room, Keifer was awake. He was sitting on his bed, holding two cups of coffee. One for him. One for her. Black, no sugar. The way she liked it.

He caught her looking and smiled.

"Good morning, Mariano."

"Good morning, Watson."

He held out the coffee.

She got up and walked across the room.

She took the coffee.

She sat down on his bed.

Everyone in the room pretended to be asleep. But Yuri was peeking. Freya was aiming her camera. Lyra was holding Alex's hand under the blankets.

Jay didn't care.

She sat on Keifer's bed, drank his coffee, and let herself feel something she'd been running from for five years.

She wasn't ready to say it back.

But she wasn't running anymore.

"One more step," she said quietly.

Keifer's heart stopped. "Yeah?"

"Yeah."

He reached for her hand.

She let him take it.

Across the room, Freya's camera clicked.

No one told her to delete it.

---

End of Chapter Seven

More Chapters