Chapter 37 : THE CLAVE'S VERDICT
The Institute's formal hearing chamber hadn't been used in decades.
Dust motes hung in the light streaming through stained glass windows depicting angelic victories that felt hollow now. The chamber had been designed for gravitas — high ceilings, carved stone walls, a raised dais where the judging authority would sit above those being judged.
Inquisitor Imogen Herondale looked entirely at home there.
"Alec Gideon Lightwood." Her voice carried the particular weight of ritual pronouncement. "You stand before this tribunal to receive the Clave's judgment on the matter of your rune modification — specifically, the evolution of a standard iratze into an undocumented pattern during the healing of your brother, Max Lightwood."
I stood at attention in the center of the chamber, Maryse to my left, Jace to my right. The parabatai bond hummed with Jace's tension — his newly-discovered grandmother judging his parabatai for heresy. The situation was exactly the kind of political nightmare the show had been built on.
"I acknowledge the charges," I said formally.
"The investigation has been... thorough." Imogen's expression gave nothing away. "Clave researchers examined the Gray Book annotations you provided. The marginalia are genuine — ancient additions that were suppressed centuries ago for reasons our records do not adequately explain."
Murmurs from the witnesses assembled in the gallery. I hadn't expected them to verify my claims so quickly.
"Furthermore," Imogen continued, "the Clave's position on rune modification has been reviewed. The Gray Book states that runes cannot be changed by Nephilim will or intent. It does not, however, address what occurs when runes change themselves under extreme stress."
A loophole. Exactly what Magnus had predicted when we'd prepared my defense.
"The Clave therefore finds the following: Alec Lightwood's evolved iratze does not constitute deliberate heresy. The modification appears to be an unprecedented but not explicitly forbidden adaptation of angelic magic under life-threatening circumstances."
Relief washed through me, but I kept my expression neutral. This wasn't over.
"However." Imogen's voice hardened. "Unprecedented events require unprecedented oversight."
Here it comes.
"You will remain as acting head of the New York Institute, pending permanent confirmation at a later date. You will submit monthly reports documenting any additional rune anomalies, power manifestations, or unusual abilities that develop. Any attempt to teach, share, or propagate evolved rune techniques requires explicit Clave approval in advance."
Monthly reports. Oversight. A leash wrapped in official language.
"Furthermore, a Clave observer will be assigned to the New York Institute to monitor compliance with these requirements."
Jace's anger flared through the bond. A spy. They were placing a spy in our Institute.
"Do you accept these conditions, Mr. Lightwood?"
"I accept them," I said, because what choice did I have?
"Then this tribunal is concluded." Imogen rose from the dais, her robes sweeping the stone floor. "The Clave's verdict is mercy tempered with caution. Do not make us regret it."
The witnesses began filing out, conversations buzzing about what they'd seen. Maryse squeezed my arm briefly — the most physical affection she'd shown me since I'd woken in this body — and followed the crowd.
But Imogen remained.
"Walk with me, Mr. Lightwood."
It wasn't a request.
The Inquisitor led me through the Institute's corridors, past Shadowhunters who pressed themselves against walls to let us pass. Her presence commanded fear even in a building that wasn't hers.
"You handled that well," she said once we were alone. "The tribunal, the questions, the formal acceptance. Very composed for someone who should be terrified."
"Should I be terrified?"
"Yes." She stopped walking, turning to face me in the hallway's shadows. "The verdict I delivered was the Clave's official position. What I'm about to say is personal."
Cold settled in my stomach.
"I know you're hiding more than stress evolution, Alexander." My full name, not the formal address. "I've interrogated enough Shadowhunters to recognize when someone is telling truth that isn't the whole truth. Your rune changed itself under stress — that much I believe. How you knew it would change, how you controlled the evolution, how you've manifested other abilities that don't appear in any report..." She smiled, and it was the smile of someone who'd spent decades breaking people. "Those are questions you haven't answered."
"I've answered everything the tribunal asked."
"The tribunal asked what the Clave wanted to know. I'm asking what I want to know." She stepped closer, and despite being shorter than me, she somehow loomed. "Jace is my blood. My grandson, miraculously returned from what I thought was death. I won't destroy his parabatai lightly — not when that destruction would hurt him as well."
"But?"
"But if you become a threat to the Nephilim..." She let the sentence hang. "I've killed men I loved to protect our people. I would kill a boy I barely know without hesitation."
The threat was delivered with the casual certainty of someone who meant every word.
"I understand, Inquisitor."
"I don't think you do. Not yet." She resumed walking, and I fell into step beside her. "Valentine escaped. His forces are scattered but not destroyed. And somewhere in the middle of this war, a young man with impossible abilities has emerged — abilities that even my researchers can't fully explain." She glanced at me sideways. "You're either an asset or a threat, Mr. Lightwood. The Clave will be watching to determine which."
We reached the portal chamber. Imogen's escort waited there, along with the swirling gateway back to Idris.
"One more thing." She paused at the portal's edge. "The observer I'm assigning to your Institute — Victor Aldertree."
My blood went cold.
Victor Aldertree. The same name Hodge had given me as a Circle sympathizer in the Clave's ranks. The man who'd helped Valentine's infiltrators get information.
"I trust him implicitly," Imogen continued, watching my face. "He's been a loyal servant of the Clave for twenty years."
He's been Valentine's mole for longer than that.
"I look forward to working with him," I said, keeping my voice steady.
Imogen stepped through the portal and vanished.
I stood alone in the chamber, counting the new chains wrapped around me. Official oversight. Monthly reports. And now a Valentine loyalist positioned inside my Institute, watching my every move.
At least I know who he is. That's more than most assets get.
The portal's light faded. Somewhere below, I heard Maryse calling for me.
I had work to do.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.