For most of that autumn nobody sat on Hamo's bench.
It stood where it had always stood, against the warm south wall of the schoolhouse by the door, a plain plank on two stone blocks, worn pale in the middle where the old man had sat for years in decent weather with a blanket over his knees. Nobody moved it. Nobody said anything about it. But the children went round it, the way water goes round a stone, and played their games at the other end of the yard, and when it rained the puddle under it lay undisturbed for days.
Osbern wanted it taken away. He said so to Cecily, at the end of the first fortnight, in a voice that was not quite steady.
"They look at it," he said. "The little ones. They walk past and look at it and go quiet. It isn't good for them."
"It isn't good for you," said Cecily. "That's different." Not unkindly, she put a hand on his arm. "Leave it. They'll decide what to do with it. Children always do. Give them a season."
Edmund decided first, though he did not tell anyone that was what he was doing.
He came out into the yard at the midday break one grey day in the second month, with his bread in his hand, and instead of going to the corner by the wall where the older boys stood and talked about nothing, he walked across the whole width of the yard and sat down on the bench.
The yard noticed. The yard always noticed. A dozen games faltered and started up again, more quietly.
Edmund ate his bread. He did not look at anyone. He had grown a great deal over the summer and did not yet know what to do with his legs, which stuck out in front of him on the wet ground. He sat in the exact place where the plank was worn pale, and it was warm from the wall behind it, and he thought about the old man holding his slate at arm's length in the sun and saying no.
He had never told anyone about that. Not his mother, not his father, not Alaric. He had kept it, the way he kept the coin and the bag of pennies, somewhere he did not look at often. He had not liked the old man much, that day. He had liked Master Osbern's very good much better. It had taken him most of four years to understand that the very good had been worth nothing and the no had been worth a great deal, and by the time he understood it the old man was on his bolsters behind a shuttered window, and Edmund had not known how to go and say so.
So he sat on the bench instead. It seemed the nearest thing.
"That's a dead man's seat."
Edmund looked up. The dyer's son was standing in front of him -- the same boy who had stopped him by the wall on his first day and told him his father's columns had made the town poor. He was fourteen now, broad and blue-fingered and starting a moustache that was not going well. He had two friends behind him, as he always did. Edmund was fairly sure they were not the same two.
"I know," said Edmund.
"So get off it. It's bad luck."
"Then it's my bad luck."
The dyer's son looked at him with the frank contempt of an older boy for a younger one who has failed to be frightened.
"You think you're him," he said. "Sitting there. You think you get to be the one everyone asks things." He laughed. "The founder's son. Course you do. Your da built the whole valley, you might as well have the old man's seat as well. Take everything, you lot."
Edmund felt his face go hot. He felt the yard listening. He felt, very clearly, the words he wanted to say -- something about the dyer's father, and the columns, and who had been right about the Whitcombe orders in the end -- and he felt how good it would be to say them, and how the yard would laugh.
He did not say them. He did not know, afterward, why not. He thought it might have been the bench. It was hard to say a cruel thing while sitting in the place where the old man had never said one.
"I don't think I'm him," he said instead. "I just wanted to sit here."
The dyer's son stared at him, waiting for the rest. There wasn't any rest. After a while he made a noise of disgust and went off to the other end of the yard, and his friends went with him, and the games went on.
Edmund sat on the bench and finished his bread and found that his hands were shaking.
The little girl came up the next day.
She was perhaps six, one of the new scholars, a dyer's daughter as it happened, though not the same family -- small and thin, with a runny nose and a direct gaze. She had clearly been dared. Edmund could see the darers at the corner of the yard, giggling. She walked up to the bench and stood in front of him with her hands behind her back, exactly as the children used to stand in front of Hamo, and said, very fast, as though she had rehearsed it:
"Why does the moon change shape?"
Edmund looked at her.
He knew the answer. He had heard his father explain it once, at supper, with an apple and a candle, and he had understood perhaps half of it. He opened his mouth to give the half he understood, and the words began to assemble themselves, the clever version, the one that would make the girl's eyes go round and the darers at the corner stop giggling.
And he heard, as clearly as if the old man were sitting beside him, a dry voice saying: they are not looking at your letters. They are looking at your father.
He closed his mouth. He thought about it honestly.
"I don't really know," he said. "I know some of it. It's to do with the sun shining on it, and which bit we can see from here. My da could tell you properly. I only know half."
The girl considered this with a frown.
"The old man always said he didn't know," she said.
"I know."
"Then he'd tell you to find out." She sniffed. "And come and tell him. And hurry."
"He can't be told now," said Edmund.
"You could tell me," said the girl, "instead," and turned and ran back to the darers before he could answer.
He did find out. He asked his father that night, and his father fetched an apple and a candle and did it again, slowly, and this time Edmund made him go back and do the part he had not understood before, twice, and at the end he understood all of it.
Thomas looked at him across the kitchen table with an expression Edmund could not read.
"Why do you want to know? You didn't care, the last time."
"Somebody asked me," said Edmund. "At school."
He did not explain further. His father did not ask him to. The next day he went and found the little girl at the break and told her about the moon, properly, all of it, with two pebbles and the sun coming over the schoolhouse roof, and she listened with her mouth open and then said "Oh," and ran away to tell the others.
Osbern saw. He came across the yard afterward, beaming, and put a hand on Edmund's shoulder, and said in his carrying voice that it was a fine thing, a very fine thing, to see the founder's son honouring the old man's memory by teaching the little ones from his very seat, and that Edmund was a credit to his family and to the school.
Edmund thanked him.
He found that he was pleased. He found that he was very pleased indeed. And he found, at the same time, under the pleasure, a small cold voice that sounded like Hamo, saying that Master Osbern had not been listening to the moon at all, and that the girl had been, and that only one of those two things was worth having.
He held both. He did not yet know how to choose between them. He would not, for a long time.
Alys had watched the whole thing from the schoolhouse window. She watched most things. She watched her brother sit on the dead man's bench, and stand up to the dyer's son without hitting him, and tell a six-year-old he did not know something, and then come back and tell her he did.
That night, on the underside of the bed-board, she made a mark. It was the first one she had ever made that was not about something hidden.
She made it, she decided, for the opposite. For a thing she had seen someone do that nobody had asked them to and nobody would ever thank them for. She did not know yet whether those marks belonged on the same board. She put it at the other end, a long way from the others, and left room.
