Cherreads

Chapter 309 - Chapter 309: Piers Abroad

The news came in the dead of that winter, from a carter, which was how most news came that was not meant to.

He was a Harrowden man, from the next March over to the west, and he had brought a load of salt up the long road in weather that should have kept him at home, and he sat in the crossroads tavern that night drying his boots at the fire and talking, the way carters talk, about everything he had seen on the way.

One of the things he had seen was a tower.

"On the ridge above Harrowden," he said. "New. Built this last summer. Tall as yours, near enough. With an arm on top that goes up and down." He made the motion with his hand. "Lord Revel had it put up. Him that holds the western March. And another one past it, on the next hill, and they're building a third." He drank. "Signals, they say. Like yours. A message from one end of his March to the other inside a morning."

Gib, who was at the next table, set down his cup.

"Who built them?"

"Couldn't tell you the masons. But the man who runs them --" the carter frowned, remembering. "Young fellow. Long face. Talks like he's reading from a book. Said he'd learned his trade here, in your valley. At your school." He shrugged. "Piers, his name was. Nice enough. Bought me a drink."

Gib came up the hill the next morning and told Thomas, standing in the kitchen with snow melting off his shoulders.

Thomas did not say anything for some time.

He remembered Piers. He remembered a long-faced young man at the top of the near tower, a winter night, his arms folded, telling the founder of the valley that he did not care whose boy Edmund was, the shutter was logged. He remembered liking him for it. He remembered putting his son's hands under Piers's on the lever and watching a light go out across the dark and come back.

Piers had left the valley two years ago, after his term at the tower. He had said he wanted to see something of the country. Nobody had thought anything of it. A good many of Cecily's scholars left, in the end. That had always been the point of them.

"He's building signal towers," Thomas said, "for a lord of the March."

"That's what the man said." Gib wiped his face. "I thought you'd want to know."

"I did." Thomas looked out of the window at the near tower on the ridge, black against the snow. "I'm not sure I wanted to."

He raised it at the council, and it went worse than he expected, and the person who made it go worse was Cecily.

"I don't understand what you want us to do," she said. "Piers finished his time. He was owed nothing and he owed nothing. He left. He took what he'd learned with him, because that's what learning is. He's using it." She spread her hands. "That was the whole idea of the school. That's what we've been doing for twenty years. Training people and letting them go."

"We've been training weavers and clerks and midwives," said Thomas. "Not signal-masters for a lord with an army."

"We trained Piers to be a signal-master. For us. We built a tower and needed someone to run it, so we taught him." Cecily did not raise her voice. "What did you think would happen when he left?"

"I didn't think he would leave."

"Then you didn't think."

There was a silence round the table. Diccon looked at the ceiling. Alaric looked at his hands.

"A signal line isn't a loom," Thomas said, more carefully. "It's an advantage in war. A lord who can send a message across his March in a morning can move men across it in a day while his neighbour's still waiting for a rider. We built our towers to warn us. Revel will build his to command. And he has a neighbour." He looked round the table. "That neighbour is us."

"So we should have kept Piers here," said Cecily. "Forever. At the top of our tower. So that nobody else could have what he knows."

"I didn't say that."

"You're saying it now. You're saying knowledge is dangerous when it walks out of the gate." She leaned forward. "I thought that was the one thing we'd never say. I thought you were the one who said it would be a crime to say it. You stood in this room and argued for the Codex to go out to anyone who could read it, and Maud argued against you, and you won. I was there. I remember what you said."

Thomas remembered what he had said too. He had said that knowledge kept in one place died with that place. That a thing worth knowing was worth giving away. That the only way to make sure it outlived any of them was to scatter it so wide no lord or bishop or fire could ever gather it all back.

He had believed it. He still believed it.

He had not, he realised, sitting at that table in the winter light, ever imagined it walking out of the gate with a face he knew.

"It was different," he said, and heard how it sounded.

"H

"How?"

x

He did not have an answer that was not a bad one.

It was Victoria who found the road out, as she often did, and she did it without taking either side.

"Write to him," she said. "Piers. Not as the council. As yourself. Ask him what he's building and why. He'll answer. He was always the kind of young man who answers." She looked at Cecily. "And we keep training people. And we let them go. And we get used to finding out where they went." She looked at Thomas. "That was always going to be the cost. You just didn't want to pay it with someone you'd met."

Thomas wrote that night. It took him several drafts. The first two were angry and he burned them. The third was careful, and courteous, and asked plainly what Lord Revel meant to do with a signal line, and whether Piers had thought about it.

The answer came at the end of the winter. It was in Piers's neat, bookish hand, and it was not long.

Master Thomas. I was glad to have your letter. I have thought about what you ask. Lord Revel wants the towers for the reason any lord would -- to know quicker, and to act quicker. I will not pretend he only wants them for warning. I asked him myself, and he did not pretend either, which I respected.

You asked if I had thought about it. I have. I thought about it on the ridge above your valley every night for four years, with nothing to do between the checks but think. And what I thought was this: you taught us that what we learned was ours. Mistress Cecily said it on the first day. Master Hamo said it in the yard. You said it yourself, at the school, the winter you taught the older scholars about levers and nobody understood you. Knowledge belongs to whoever learns it. You were very clear. I believed you.

So I have taken what was mine and gone where I could use it. I would not do anything against the valley. I would like you to know that. But I am not the valley's any more. I am my own. That is what you made us.

With respect, and with thanks, and with the shutter logged -- Piers.

Thomas read it twice at the kitchen table. Then he handed it across to Victoria, who read it once, and handed it back.

"He's right," she said.

"I know."

"You trained him to be right. That's the trouble with training people well." She picked up her pen again. "They grow up and use it on you."

Margery had been at the end of the table the whole time, eating her supper, saying nothing. She was seven. Nobody had thought to send her out.

The next morning, at the workshop, she asked Maud a question, in her careful way, after a long time weighing it.

"Is it bad when people take what they learned somewhere else?"

Maud looked up from her drawing.

"Who's been saying that?"

"Nobody. Da got a letter. He didn't like it." Margery considered. "But he said it was right. And Mam said it was right. And he still didn't like it."

Maud put down her pen. She looked at the child for a long while.

"Your father," she said slowly, "believes that knowledge should go everywhere, to everyone, as fast as it can. He has believed that for as long as I've known him. I argued with him about it, years ago, in front of the whole council, and I lost."

"Why did you argue?"

"Because I'd seen what happens when it goes everywhere badly. Half-learned. Half-copied. In the wrong hands, or the right hands with the wrong half." Maud's face was very still. "I saw a fever house in Pisa once, built from a copy of something your father wrote. They'd got it wrong. Not much. Just enough." She picked her pen up again. "That's why I argued. And I lost. And he was mostly right, and I was a little bit right, and nobody wants to hear about the little bit."

Margery thought about this for the rest of the morning, sorting nothing, filing nothing, sitting at the long bench with her hands in her lap.

"I want to hear about the little bit," she said at last.

Maud did not look up. But she said nothing for some time, and then she said, "Come here. I'll tell you about Pisa," and Margery went.

"How?"

More Chapters