Cherreads

Chapter 311 - Chapter 311: The Eldest at Home

Alys presented her case at breakfast, in writing, three days after the Sunday hour.

She had written it on the back of one of Edmund's spoiled copying sheets, in her round careful hand, and she laid it beside her mother's bowl without a word and sat down and began eating her porridge as if nothing had happened. Victoria looked at it. Thomas, across the table, saw her look at it, and saw her mouth do something it was trying very hard not to do.

"What is this?"

"A petition," said Alys. "Like Hawise's. For the lord."

"I'm not a lord."

"You're the one deciding." Alys did not look up from her porridge. "So you're the lord of this."

Victoria read it. Thomas could see it was not short.

One. I can keep the tally of costs on the road, because I do the house tally already when Joan is at the fever house, and I have never got it wrong. Two. I know the Genoese money, because I read Master Corradino's letters when you leave them on the table, and I have copied out what everything is worth. Three. I am not sick in carts. Hugh is sick in carts. Margery is not sick in carts but she would not talk to anyone. Four. You said old enough to be useful and young enough to be carried. I am nine. Edmund is eleven and too big to be carried. Five. I would be very good.

Victoria set the sheet down.

"You were on the landing," she said.

Alys ate a spoonful of porridge.

"On Sunday. During the hour. You were on the landing with your ear to the gap."

"The floor creaks," said Alys, "if you stand on the wrong board. I stood on the right board."

"You stood on the wrong board twice. We heard you both times."

Alys considered this with real interest. "Which one?"

"I'm not going to tell you that," said Victoria, "because then you'd never stand on it again." She picked up the petition. "Point two. You've been reading my letters."

"Only the ones on the table."

"All my letters are on the table."

"Then all of them," Alys agreed.

Thomas put his hand over his mouth and looked out of the window for a while.

Edmund came down late, which was usual, and found the petition being passed between his parents, which was not.

He read it over his father's shoulder. Thomas felt him go still.

"You're going to Genoa?"

"Your mother is going to Genoa," said Thomas. "This summer. With the convoy. She may take one of you."

Edmund looked at his sister. Alys looked at her porridge.

"I'm the eldest," said Edmund.

"You are."

"So I should go." He said it as a plain fact, the way he said things he had worked out. "I'm the eldest. I'm on Alaric's Thursdays. I know about trade, I've copied the whole Bramwell correspondence. I can talk to merchants. She's nine. She just reads letters off the table."

"I read them properly," said Alys, without looking up.

"You eavesdrop."

"So do you." Now she looked up. Her face was perfectly calm. "You listen on the gallery stair. Every council day. I listen on the landing. We're the same."

Edmund went white, and then red.

The table was very quiet. Thomas looked at his son and saw the boy realise, in the space of a breath, that his sister had known about the stair -- perhaps for years -- and had never said a word, and had chosen this moment to say it, in front of both their parents, as calmly as if she were reporting the price of alum.

"That's not the same," said Edmund, in a voice that was not quite steady. "Alaric knows about the stair. I copy for him. I'm allowed."

"Nobody said I wasn't allowed on the landing."

"Enough," said Victoria.

They both stopped.

She did not decide that morning. She said she would think about it, and she sent them both off to school, and when the door had shut behind them she sat for a long while with Alys's petition in front of her and her chin on her hand.

"It's Alys," said Thomas.

"Yes."

"You knew it was Alys before she wrote that."

"I knew it was Alys when I said one of them, on Sunday." Victoria did not look up. "I didn't know she'd argue for it. That was a pleasant surprise. Point four was very well judged. She found the exact words I'd used and turned them against her brother."

"Edmund will take it hard."

"Edmund will take it very hard." She turned the sheet over, as if there might be more on the back. "I've thought about him. I have. He's older. He'd be useful. He'd probably behave well." A pause. "And he would walk into every counting house in Genoa as the founder's son. He wouldn't mean to. He wouldn't say it. But he'd stand that way. And every merchant in that city would look at him and see you."

"And Alys?"

"Alys would walk into every counting house in Genoa and sit in the corner and watch. And in a month she would know more about that city than I will." Victoria folded the petition. "Edmund wants to be seen. Alys wants to see. Genoa is for seeing."

Thomas was silent for a moment.

"That isn't a reason you can give him."

"No. It isn't." She looked at him. "So I'm going to give him a different reason, and it's going to be true, and it isn't going to help."

She told them at supper.

"Alys comes with me," she said. "Edmund stays."

Alys did not say anything. She put down her spoon, carefully, and folded her hands in her lap, and her face did a great many things in a short time and settled on nothing at all. Thomas, watching her, thought that he had never seen a child try so hard not to look pleased.

Edmund did not say anything either. He sat very straight.

"I need you here," said Victoria, to him. She said it plainly, not as a consolation. "Your father will have three children and a council and a summer's worth of work, and Alaric's hands are not what they were, and somebody in this house needs to be old enough to be left in charge of things when your father is at the tally-bench. That is you. You're the eldest at home."

"The eldest at home," Edmund repeated.

"Yes."

He looked at her for a while. Thomas watched him turn the words over -- the way he turned everything over, checking it for weak joints -- and watched him find the weak joint, and press on it, and feel it give.

"Alys gets Genoa," he said, "and I get Hugh."

"You get the house," said Thomas. "That's not nothing. I'm going to need you."

"You don't need me. You need someone to watch Hugh while you're at the tally-bench." Edmund's voice was quite level. "That's what the eldest at home means. It means the one who stays."

Nobody answered that, because there was no answer to it that was not either a lie or a kinder version of the same thing.

Edmund finished his supper. He thanked his mother for it, politely. He went up to bed early, without being told, and Thomas heard his door close -- not slammed, which would have been easier, but closed very quietly, the way you close a door on a room you intend to stay in for a long time.

Alys came to find her brother later, after everyone else was down.

Thomas did not see it. He heard about it years afterward, from Alys, when she was grown and running half the March's dealings and he was old enough to be told things. She had crept along the landing -- on the right board -- and pushed open Edmund's door, and found him sitting on his bed in the dark with the box from under it open on his knees, holding the Genoa coin.

"I'll bring you something back," she had said. "From Genoa."

"I don't want anything."

"I'll bring you something anyway." She had hesitated in the doorway. "I didn't write the petition to beat you. I didn't know you wanted to go, when I wrote it. You never said."

"I'm the eldest. I shouldn't have had to say."

Alys had thought about that for a long time, standing in the dark.

"I think," she had said at last, "that in this house you always have to say. Everyone knows things and nobody says them. So you have to."

Edmund had not answered. She had gone back to bed.

She did bring him something back from Genoa, in the end. He kept it. But he never, then or later, said to anyone out loud that it had hurt -- and Alys, who kept count of such things, made a mark for it on the underside of her bed-board that night, at the end of the board where the hidden things were, and did not know until much later that it was the most important one she ever made.

More Chapters