They left on a soft grey morning at the end of spring, with the hawthorn out along the ridge road and a fine rain that could not decide whether to fall.
Half the household came down to the gate. Victoria was on the brown mare, with her saddlebags packed and repacked and packed again, and her face set in the expression she wore for council days and difficult merchants. Alys was on the small grey pony that Diccon had found for her, sitting very straight, in a new cloak that was slightly too big, with a leather satchel across her body that she had not let anyone else touch since it was given to her. It held a tally-book, a quill case, three sheets of Genoese coin values copied out in her own hand, and -- Thomas happened to know -- a small carved wooden horse of Hugh's that she had taken without asking and would, he suspected, give back at the end of the summer with an elaborate account of its travels.
They would ride to Whitcombe that day and join the convoy there. Five weeks to Genoa. Thomas had looked at the route on Elias's old maps so many times in the past month that he could have drawn it blind.
"You have the list," said Victoria, from the saddle.
"I have the list."
"You have both lists. The house and the tally-bench."
"I have both lists."
"Read them."
"I have read them."
"Read them again tonight," said Victoria. "You won't have read them properly. Nobody ever reads my lists properly the first time. That is why I write them."
Hugh, at the gate, was waving at nothing in particular, with great enthusiasm. Margery stood beside him with her hands behind her back and her eyes on her mother, and did not wave, and did not say anything, and did not need to.
Edmund was not there.
Thomas had knocked on his door at first light. There had been no answer. When he had pushed it open, the bed was made and the room was empty and the box under the bed was gone from its usual place. He had not looked further. He thought he knew roughly where the boy was, and he thought that if Edmund had wanted to be found he would not have made his bed.
Victoria looked up the lane once, toward the house. Then she did not look again.
"Go on," said Thomas, "or you'll miss the light at Whitcombe."
Victoria leaned down from the saddle. She did not kiss him; there were people at the gate, and Victoria did not do that in front of people. She put her hand flat against his chest for a moment, over his heart, over the place where the dead stone sat in his tunic pocket, and held it there.
"Don't hover," she said.
"I won't."
"You will. Hover at them, not at me. I'll be on the other side of the mountains. You can't hover that far."
"I won't."
"You will," said Victoria, "and I forgive you in advance."
She turned the mare. Alys turned the pony after her, with a look back over her shoulder at her father that was half triumph and half something much younger and less certain. And they went down the lane together in the soft rain, past the mill and the dye-works, and the weavers came out of their doorways to watch them go, and somebody at the corner called out a blessing, and Victoria lifted a hand without turning round.
Thomas watched them all the way to the turn at the mill.
It was Margery who saw it first. She tugged his sleeve, once, and pointed.
Up on the ridge, at the foot of the near tower, very small against the grey sky, there was a figure standing on the rocks. It was too far to see a face. It did not need a face. It stood perfectly still, watching the road, and as the two riders came to the turn below it, it lifted one arm, high, and held it there.
Down on the road, the smaller rider turned in her saddle and looked up. Thomas saw her see it. He saw her lift her own arm, the too-big cloak falling back from it, and hold it up in return.
Then the road turned, and they were gone, and the figure on the ridge stood a moment longer with its arm still raised, and then lowered it, and went back behind the tower out of sight.
Margery let go of his sleeve.
"That was Edmund," she said.
"Yes," said Thomas.
"He said he wasn't coming."
"He didn't come," said Thomas. "He went up there instead."
Margery considered the difference with her usual care, and seemed to find it acceptable.
The first evening was a disaster, and it was a disaster in a way Thomas had not prepared for, because it was wholly about supper.
He had cooked before. He had cooked a great deal, in his first years in the valley, badly, and then in the plague years, out of necessity, slightly less badly. He had not cooked for four children in a long time, and he had not, he discovered, the faintest idea where anything was kept, or how much of it to use, or in what order things were supposed to happen so that they arrived at the table at the same time instead of in a slow procession of burnt and raw.
The pottage caught. The bread was from yesterday. He could not find the salt.
"It's in the crock by the window," said a voice from the doorway.
Thomas looked up. Edmund was standing there, damp from the ridge, with his box under his arm and his face carefully empty.
"The salt," said Edmund. "It's in the crock by the window. Not the one by the hearth. That one's the oats. Mam moved them at Candlemas."
Thomas found the salt. It was in the crock by the window.
Edmund came in, put his box down on the bench, and looked at the pot.
"You've let it catch."
"I know I've let it catch."
"You have to stir it from the bottom, not the top. And you put the barley in too soon. It goes in after the onions are soft, not before." Edmund took the spoon out of his father's hand, quite calmly, as though this were a thing he did every day, and began stirring from the bottom. "Mam showed me. Last winter. When you were at the council late."
Thomas stood in his own kitchen and watched his son rescue the supper.
He wanted, very much, to be annoyed. He had been annoyed all afternoon, at nothing, at the rain and the empty chair and the list in Victoria's hand that he had now read three times and still did not fully understand. He found the annoyance rising, and found that it had nowhere to land, because the boy was right about the barley and right about the salt and was standing at the hearth doing a thing his father did not know how to do.
"Where did you go this morning?" he said instead.
Edmund did not look round from the pot.
"Up the ridge."
"I saw."
The spoon stopped for a heartbeat. Then it went on.
"I didn't want to do it at the gate," said Edmund. "With everyone watching." A pause. "She saw me, though. Alys. She waved."
"She did."
"Good," said Edmund, and went on stirring, and said nothing else about it.
That night, after they were all down -- Hugh asleep in a heap, Margery asleep with her hands folded like a small effigy, Edmund's candle out for once -- Thomas sat at the kitchen table and read Victoria's lists again, properly, line by line.
They were very long. They covered everything. Which of the children ate what, and which would claim not to. Which of Hugh's complaints meant nothing and which meant send for Joan. When the miller's boy came with the flour and what he would try to charge. Which drawer the good knives were in. The salt, in the crock by the window.
At the very bottom of the house list, under everything else, in a slightly different ink, as if added at the last moment:
Edmund knows where everything is. He has been watching me all winter. Let him show you. Do not let him do all of it.
Thomas sat with that line for a long time.
Then he got up and went to the bottom of the stairs, and stood there in the dark looking up toward his son's closed door, and thought about the eldest at home, and about a boy on a ridge with his arm raised, and about how long it had taken him, as a father, to notice what his wife had written down in a single sentence.
He did not go up. He went back to the table and read the tally-bench list instead, all of it, twice, and did not go to bed until very late.
