Chapter 35: The Cabbie — Part 3
[Moriarty's Flat, Southwark — August 8, 2010, 11:00 PM]
Hope was getting sloppy.
The excitement—the particular narcotic of validation that came from proving, finally, that a cab driver from Southwark was smarter than his passengers—had infected his operational discipline. He was taking risks. Driving faster. Choosing victims impulsively rather than methodically. His latest fare had required two attempts with the pill routine because the first approach had spooked the potential victim, who'd jumped out of the cab at a red light and run.
"He's escalating," Moran reported. "Two more days, maybe three, before he makes a mistake big enough to get caught."
"Good," James said.
"Good?"
"Hope getting caught was always the endgame. He can't run forever—he's dying, and dying people get careless. The police will catch him, or he'll collapse, or both. What matters is what he says when they do."
James had given Hope one instruction for the endgame. Simple. Absolute. "When they ask who you work for, you say one word: Moriarty."
Hope hadn't understood why. He didn't need to. He was a weapon with a timer, designed to fire once—at the detective who'd be standing closest when the mechanism triggered.
---
[Roland-Kerr Further Education College, Brixton — August 9, 2010, 10:30 PM]
James wasn't there. His protocols—the architecture of separation that he'd spent two years constructing—prohibited presence at operational sites. The spider didn't crawl down the web.
But Priya was there. Or rather, Priya's technology was there—a passive audio receiver planted in the college building three days earlier, during a routine security assessment that Holt had conducted under contract. The receiver fed to a relay that fed to Priya's monitoring station, which fed to James's earpiece in the Southwark flat, forty minutes of delay compressed to real-time through equipment that would have been military-grade if the military had known about it.
He listened.
Hope's cab arriving. Footsteps—two sets, one confident, one shuffling. Hope's voice, reedy and triumphant: explaining the game, the pills, the choice. The methodology that James had refined from Hope's crude original into something that mimicked psychological coercion with the precision of a clinical trial.
Then Sherlock's voice. For the first time, unmediated by distance or surveillance footage, James heard the consulting detective speak.
The voice was precise. Fast. The particular cadence of a mind that processed information faster than language could convey it, creating a staccato delivery that sounded arrogant but was, James recognised, simply efficient. Sherlock was dissecting Hope's game in real-time—identifying the psychological pressure points, the manufactured urgency, the illusion of choice.
And then—unexpectedly, dangerously—Sherlock picked up the pill.
James leaned forward. The earpiece crackled with ambient noise—building ventilation, distant traffic, the particular acoustic signature of an empty classroom at night. Sherlock was actually considering taking the pill. Not to prove Hope wrong. To prove himself right. To test whether his deductive capability could identify the safe pill through observation alone.
He's going to do it. He's actually going to play the game.
The arrogance was breathtaking. The arrogance was also, James recognised with the clarity of someone watching a mirror, familiar. The same hunger that drove James to build an empire from a Southwark bedsit—the need to prove, to test, to know—drove Sherlock toward a pill that might kill him.
A gunshot.
The sound through the earpiece was flat, compressed by the microphone's dynamic range into something less dramatic than reality. But the effect was unmistakable. Hope's voice changed—surprise, then pain, then the wet gurgle of a man whose body had been perforated. Someone had shot through the window.
Watson. It had to be Watson. The army doctor with the psychosomatic limp and the steady hands and the moral clarity to shoot a stranger through glass to save a friend he'd known for days.
Pressure point confirmed. Watson wouldn't just ground Sherlock—he'd kill for him.
James listened to the aftermath. Sherlock's voice, urgent now, addressing the dying cabbie. "Who do you work for? Who sent you?"
Hope's breathing was failing—the wet, irregular pattern of a man whose lungs were filling with what they shouldn't contain. But the instruction held. Through the pain, through the shock, through the biological machinery of death engaging its final sequence, Hope said the word.
"Moriarty."
Then static. Then silence.
---
[Moriarty's Flat, Southwark — August 9, 2010, 11:45 PM]
James removed the earpiece. Set it on the table. Sat in the quiet.
The name was spoken. Sherlock Holmes had heard it. The seed was planted—not in the public consciousness, not in the police files, but in the one mind that mattered. The detective who solved impossible cases now had a name attached to an impossible case, and that name would burrow into his thinking the way all unsolved variables burrowed into minds that couldn't tolerate the unsolved.
James stood. Walked to the kitchen. The champagne had been chilling since that morning—a bottle of Veuve Clicquot that he'd bought because the moment deserved marking, even if the marking was private.
He popped the cork. The sound was sharp in the quiet flat. He poured a glass. Drank.
The champagne was good. Cold, dry, the bubbles precise against his tongue. He drank it standing at the kitchen counter, looking at the wall where the whiteboard hung—clean, as always, wiped after every session. No diagrams. No plans. No evidence of the two years of construction that had produced this moment.
Two years. From a man who made tea with shaking hands to a man who toasts the beginning of a war with champagne.
The thought was the kind he usually suppressed—retrospective, self-aware, dangerously close to the navel-gazing that the writing rules prohibited. But tonight, alone, with a dead man's name on a dying man's lips and a detective's curiosity ignited, he allowed it.
He refilled the glass. Drank again. The second glass tasted like the first but meant something different—celebration becoming contemplation, triumph settling into the particular heaviness of what came next.
Hope was dead. A pawn, used and discarded. James tried to feel something about that—the man had been genuine in his desperation, genuine in his desire to be remembered, genuine in his dying. But the feeling that arrived was professional rather than personal: Hope had served his purpose. The mechanism had functioned. The result had been achieved.
The numbness was either adaptation or something worse. Two years of this answer, and it hadn't changed.
His phone buzzed. Molly: Long shift. Lost a young one today. Coming home feeling hollow. Can I call you?
James set down the champagne glass. Picked up the Jim phone. Called her.
"Hey," Molly said. Her voice was tired. The particular exhaustion of a pathologist who'd performed an autopsy on someone young enough to make the procedure feel like an accusation.
"Hey. Tell me about it."
She did. A nineteen-year-old, meningitis, diagnosed too late. The parents had been in the corridor when Molly finished. She'd told them the findings. The mother had thanked her. The father had said nothing.
James listened. Held the phone. Said the things that Jim from IT would say—kind things, true things, the comfort of a man who understood loss because he'd experienced it and because the woman on the other end of the phone deserved someone who would hold the weight of her sadness without flinching.
When Molly hung up—calmer, quieter, the exhaustion shifting from acute to manageable—James sat at the table with the champagne going flat and the earpiece going cold and the two halves of his life coexisting in the same room, at the same table, separated by nothing more than which phone he picked up.
Note:
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.