Chapter 36: The Blind Banker
[Moriarty's Flat, Southwark — September 15, 2010, 2:00 PM]
The Black Lotus case landed on James's radar before it landed on Sherlock's.
Priya flagged it through the information network—two deaths linked to a Chinese smuggling operation, the kind of cross-border criminal enterprise that James's network monitored routinely. The Black Lotus Tong was known to him through second-hand intelligence: Mehmet Yilmaz's Turkish supply chain intersected with Asian trafficking routes at several points, and the resulting intelligence cross-pollination had given James a broad map of the Tong's London operations.
He didn't control them. Didn't want to. The Black Lotus was the kind of organisation that James had learned to observe rather than engage—violent, hierarchical, ideologically driven in ways that made them unpredictable and therefore dangerous as partners. But he knew their structure, their key personnel, their financial channels, and the names of three operatives who managed their London logistics.
When the murders began—a banker found dead in his locked office, a journalist killed in her flat, both connected to antiquities smuggling—James recognised the Tong's methodology. And when Scotland Yard failed to make progress, he knew what came next.
"Sherlock's taken the case," Cooper reported during their monthly debrief. They'd moved from the George to a café in Deptford—rotating locations, a protocol James enforced even for low-risk meetings. "Lestrade referred it through the usual channels. Holmes and Watson are working the banking angle."
"What's his approach?"
"Systematic. He's mapping the financial connections between the victims and the smuggling network. Tracing import records, auction house transactions, shipping manifests. Different from the cabbie case—less intuition, more analysis."
James filed the information. Sherlock's methodology adapted to the problem type. Individual criminals triggered deductive reasoning—observation, inference, the flash of insight that television had made famous. Organisations triggered analytical reasoning—pattern recognition, financial forensics, the methodical dismantling of complex structures. Both were impressive. Both had different vulnerabilities.
---
[Moriarty's Flat, Southwark — September 20, 2010, 8:00 PM]
James ate takeaway noodles at the kitchen table while reviewing Priya's surveillance reports on Sherlock's progress through the Black Lotus case.
The noodles were from a place in Borough Market—hand-pulled, spicy, the kind of food that existed because London had absorbed every cuisine on earth and made them all available within walking distance. He ate with chopsticks, which he'd learned in this life—the previous life had been forks and knives, the particular utensil conservatism of a man from Boston who'd never bothered learning. Small pleasures. The kind of thing he appreciated now in ways he hadn't before.
The surveillance reports showed Sherlock moving through the case with characteristic efficiency. He'd identified the cipher system—a book code, Chinese numerals, linked to a specific edition of a travel guide. He'd traced the smuggling network's London hub. He was closing in.
But the interesting data wasn't Sherlock's methodology. It was his personal dynamics.
Watson had a girlfriend. Sarah. She'd been drawn into the case—kidnapped by the Tong's operatives, used as leverage against Sherlock. Watson had been forced to choose between the investigation and the woman, and the choice had cost him. Not Sarah's life—Sherlock had solved the case in time—but the relationship itself. Sarah, understandably, had difficulty reconciling romantic evenings with abduction at gunpoint.
James made notes. Not in the physical notebook—nothing about Sherlock went on paper. In his head, in the architecture of assessment that he'd been building since Baker Street.
Watson was Sherlock's emotional vulnerability externalised. The detective functioned in a social vacuum—brilliant but isolated, connected to the world only through the mediating presence of the army doctor. Attack Watson's personal life, and the ripples reached Sherlock. Not directly—Sherlock would claim indifference to Watson's romantic complications—but structurally. Watson distracted was Watson unavailable. Watson unavailable was Sherlock unanchored.
The way Molly is my vulnerability. The thought arrived uninvited and unwelcome. James suppressed it with the mechanical efficiency he'd developed for inconvenient truths.
He studied the surveillance photographs. Sherlock at crime scenes—bent over evidence, eyes alive with the particular light of a mind fully engaged. Sherlock at Baker Street—pacing, violin, the restless energy of someone who experienced boredom as a physical pain. Sherlock with Watson—marginally softer, the sharp edges filed down just enough to permit proximity without drawing blood.
They were similar. James could see it now, with the clarity that distance and observation provided. Two minds that couldn't stop working, couldn't stop seeing, couldn't rest in the comfortable ignorance that most people treated as a basic human right. The difference was in the direction: Sherlock pointed his intelligence at puzzles, at crimes, at the endless project of understanding a world that confused him. James pointed his at systems, at architectures, at the endless project of controlling a world that had failed him.
Different applications. Same engine.
He finished the noodles. Washed the container. Sat back at the table with his tea—the silent kettle, the replacement that still felt wrong after nearly two years—and began planning.
The observation phase was ending. Two cases. Two data sets. Enough to build a profile of Sherlock Holmes that was, if not complete, sufficient for operational purposes. He knew the detective's strengths: deductive brilliance, fearlessness, analytical depth, adaptability. He knew the weaknesses: arrogance, boredom-driven risk-taking, emotional dependency on Watson, underestimation of variables he considered beneath his attention.
The question was no longer whether to engage Sherlock directly. The question was how.
The cabbie had been a first move—a name dropped into a dying man's confession, a whisper in the dark. The Black Lotus was a window—an opportunity to observe without being observed, to watch the detective work without becoming the subject of that work.
The next move needed to be different. Direct. Theatrical. Something that announced Moriarty not as a name but as a presence—a force that demanded engagement, that couldn't be filed away or deprioritised or solved with a single deduction. Something that would turn Sherlock Holmes's attention toward James Moriarty and hold it there, permanently, like a lens focusing light until the focal point caught fire.
The Great Game. The phrase surfaced from the degrading canon knowledge—a fragment of episode title, a memory of bombs and puzzles and a swimming pool where two men had met for the first time and recognised each other as the thing they'd been missing.
James didn't remember the details. Didn't need to. The concept was enough: a series of escalating challenges, each one designed to demonstrate that the intelligence behind them was equal to the intelligence solving them. Not random crimes. Not brute force. A conversation conducted through criminal methodology—elegant, personal, demanding a response from the only person in London capable of providing one.
You want to play, Sherlock? Here's a game worth playing.
James opened his laptop. Created a new encrypted file. Titled it: OPERATION: GREAT GAME
Underneath, in the organised architecture that two years of criminal consulting had made instinctive:
Objective: Force direct engagement with Sherlock Holmes. Demonstrate capability. Establish Moriarty as intellectual equal.
Method: Series of escalating puzzles/cases delivered directly to Holmes. Each case represents a different criminal discipline. Each case has a time constraint. Each case demonstrates a different aspect of the Moriarty network's capability.
Constraint: No harm to civilian bystanders. No involvement of Molly. No exposure of core network architecture.
Timeline: Preparation — 4 weeks. Execution — 1 week. Confrontation — TBD.
The last item was the one that mattered. Confrontation. Face to face. The moment when the name became a person and the person became an enemy and the game became real.
James typed for two hours. The plan grew. Cases, puzzles, escalations—each one a message in a language that only Sherlock Holmes would fully understand. The language of criminal intelligence, spoken fluently by two people who'd never met but who were, in every meaningful sense, already entangled.
The Molly phone buzzed. He glanced at it. A photo: Toby asleep on the forensic pathology textbook, the first edition, the Christmas gift. The cat's paw was resting on Keith Simpson's name.
Even Toby appreciates good literature 📚🐈
James typed back: Toby has excellent taste. As does his owner.
He set the phone down. Looked at the laptop screen. Looked at the phone. Two worlds. Two lives. The space between them had never been wider, and the man standing in that space had never been more aware that the ground he occupied was narrowing toward a point where only one version of himself could survive.
The Great Game would bring Sherlock Holmes into his orbit. It would also bring James Moriarty out of the shadows and into the light—the particular, merciless light of a detective who saw everything and a world that would, eventually, demand to know who was behind the name.
James closed the laptop. The flat was dark. London hummed its permanent low note through the walls.
He picked up the phone. Called Moran.
"I need five cases. Unconnected. Different criminal types. Each one solvable but complex. Each one with a time component—deadline, countdown, consequence for failure. And each one needs a communication channel to Sherlock Holmes. Direct. Personal. He needs to know the cases are for him."
"Timeline?"
"Four weeks to prepare. Then we go."
"And the endgame?"
"A meeting. Just him and me. Somewhere memorable."
Silence. Then Moran: "I'll start sourcing cases. Any restrictions?"
"No civilians harmed in the delivery. The cases themselves can involve historical crimes, cold cases, unsolved puzzles. The violence is in the pressure, not the execution."
"Understood. And Jim—"
"Yes?"
"When you meet him. What then?"
James looked at the dark window. His reflection looked back—pale, composed, the face of a man who'd lived two lives and was about to begin a third.
"Then we see who's smarter."
Note:
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.