Chapter 15 : The Frank Effect
Paddy's Pub, South Philadelphia — January, 2006
The first Frank-enhanced scheme starts on a Wednesday, and Griffin knows it's coming the way you know a train is coming when you live next to the tracks — not from seeing it, but from the vibration in the floor.
Charlie is in a wheelchair.
Not because Charlie is injured. Because Frank Reynolds decided over breakfast that insurance fraud is "the smart play" and Charlie's commitment to physical performance — honed over years of faking cancer, faking pregnancy scares, faking everything — makes him the ideal candidate. The wheelchair is rented. The story is fabricated. The target is the insurance company that covers Paddy's Pub, and the payout Frank is projecting would fund the bar for a year.
The CPS rates it before Charlie even sits down.
B
[SCHEME DISASTER RATING: B — BEDLAM. INSURANCE FRAUD: MODERATE SEVERITY. PHYSICAL RISK: ELEVATED (CHARLIE). FINANCIAL RISK: HIGH (ALL PARTICIPANTS). LAW ENFORCEMENT PROBABILITY: 43%. FRANK MODIFIER: ACTIVE.]
B-tier. Higher than anything in Season 1. Higher than Fight Night, which was the previous ceiling. Frank has been at Paddy's for six days and the baseline has already shifted — the CPS confirmed what Griffin's legal pad predicted, that Frank's money multiplies every scheme by a factor that turns embarrassment into bedlam and disruption into catastrophe.
Griffin warned them. Of course he warned them.
"Insurance fraud is a felony. The investigator will see through it in a week."
Frank, from his new position at the end of the bar — the spot that used to be nobody's and is now permanently Frank's, the way territorial animals claim a tree: "Kid, I've been committing fraud since before you were born. The trick is confidence."
"The trick is not getting caught."
"Same thing."
Charlie wheels past in the rented chair, arms pumping with an enthusiasm that undermines the "crippled" narrative. "I'm getting really good at this. Watch." He pops a wheelie. The chair tips. Charlie catches himself on the bar.
"Charlie, crippled people don't do wheelies."
"SOME crippled people do wheelies. The cool ones."
COMPLICITY: 19%
Griffin goes back behind the bar. The warning bounced. The achievement will come later — Bronze #5, probably, another "I Mentioned It" to add to the collection, another 2% on Sarcasm Timing pushing the total toward a number that makes his one-liners land with surgical precision and changes absolutely nothing about the outcome.
The insurance scheme unfolds over three days. Charlie commits to the wheelchair with the intensity of a method actor whose method is chaos. He wheels into convenience stores and demands accessible accommodations. He wheels down Broad Street and collects sympathy that he converts, somehow, into free meals. He wheels into the insurance office and files a claim that Frank wrote on the back of a bar napkin and contains at least four spelling errors.
The investigator arrives on Friday. She's a woman in her forties with a clipboard and the specific exhaustion of someone who has seen every variation of this scam and is tired of pretending they're novel. She watches Charlie for fifteen minutes. Charlie, sensing surveillance, overcommits — he falls out of the wheelchair, writhes on the floor, and screams about his "back thing" while Frank coaches from the corner with hand signals a blind person could read.
The claim is denied. Frank threatens legal action. The investigator threatens prosecution. Frank backs down, because Frank's criminal instincts know when to press and when to fold, and this is a fold. The wheelchair goes back to the rental company. Charlie walks fine. The Gang argues about whose fault it was — Dennis blames Frank's strategy, Frank blames Charlie's performance, Charlie blames the wheelchair ("it didn't have good vibes"), and Mac blames the investigator's "lack of vision."
[ACHIEVEMENT UNLOCKED: "I MENTIONED IT" (BRONZE) — +2% SARCASM TIMING]
Sarcasm Timing: +14% total. The number climbs and the pattern holds: predict, warn, get dismissed, watch the disaster, receive a medal. The Cassandra loop, now sponsored by a system that rewards suffering with comedic upgrades.
---
Paddy's Pub — The Following Week
The next scheme doesn't wait.
Mac describes it as "strategic expansion." Dennis frames it as "asserting territorial dominance." Frank calls it "going jihad," a phrase that makes Griffin's jaw tighten because it's 2006 and the word carries weight that nobody in this room is equipped to handle responsibly.
The scheme is simple and insane: the bar next door — a Korean restaurant that recently extended its hours into Paddy's evening trade — is competition, and the Gang's response to competition is not innovation or improvement but escalation. Frank provides funding. Dennis provides rhetoric. Mac provides muscle he doesn't have. Charlie provides chaos nobody asked for.
The CPS rates it the moment the word "jihad" leaves Frank's mouth.
A
Not the unstable A of Frank's arrival — this one is steady, confident, fully calculated. Deep red, pulsing with the slow rhythm of a system that has processed the variables and reached a conclusion it wishes it hadn't.
[SCHEME DISASTER RATING: A — APOCALYPTIC. PROPERTY DAMAGE: SEVERE. CRIMINAL EXPOSURE: HIGH. COLLATERAL: NEIGHBORING BUSINESSES, CIVILIANS. FRANK MODIFIER: ACTIVE. INVOLVEMENT ESCALATION: WEAPONS DETECTED.]
Weapons detected.
Frank has produced, from somewhere Griffin doesn't want to know about, materials that fall into the category of "things civilians should not possess." The specifics are vague from behind the bar — Griffin sees containers, tubing, what might be firecrackers or might be something worse. The CPS can't give him a detailed breakdown at Phase 1 — no Collateral Damage Forecast, no individual risk assessments, just the broad-stroke A and the knowledge that "weapons detected" is a phrase his system has never displayed before.
Griffin doesn't just warn them. He steps out from behind the bar, puts both hands flat on the surface, and says it directly to Frank.
"This will end with arrests. Multiple arrests. Property damage. Possibly fire."
Frank looks at him. The look is not hostile — Frank's look is never hostile toward the bartender, because the bartender is infrastructure, not competition. It's the look of a man processing an input he doesn't value.
"Kid, I've gone jihad on seven businesses. Trust the process."
"The process involves felony arson."
"Only if they PROVE it's arson."
Mac, from behind Frank: "Griffin, you are LITERALLY the most negative person in all of Philadelphia."
The callback lands in Griffin's memory — Mac said the same thing the night of the first rebranding argument, and during Fight Night, and during every warning since. The words are identical each time, delivered with the same dismissive wave, the same unshakeable certainty that Griffin's pessimism is a personality flaw rather than a data-driven observation. The Cassandra pattern doesn't evolve. It repeats.
COMPLICITY: 24%
Griffin goes to the stockroom. Sits on the Yuengling case — the same case he sat on the morning the CPS activated, when Charlie was pitching rat meat and the first E-tier rating appeared above his head like a pilot light for the rest of his life. That E seems quaint now. A relic of the pre-Frank era, when the worst thing that could happen at Paddy's was mild embarrassment and a wasted afternoon.
The stockroom is quiet. The HUD dims. Griffin closes his eyes and counts his heartbeats — a trick he learned during the insurance scheme, a way to let the system settle into background noise while his body processes the adrenaline of watching five people plan something that would be a crime in any jurisdiction and a war crime in some.
Seventy-two. Seventy-three. Seventy-four.
The sounds from the bar filter through the door. Frank's voice — loud, commanding, the voice of a man who has never been told no by anyone he respects, which is nobody. Charlie's enthusiasm. Mac's agreement. Dennis's competing vision. Dee, somewhere, trying to contribute.
Eighty-one. Eighty-two.
Sirens. Not inside — outside. Close, then closer, then right outside the door.
The jihad scheme resolves at A-tier.
Griffin doesn't see the resolution. He stays in the stockroom through the sirens, through the shouting, through the sound of something breaking that might be glass or might be pride. When he comes out, the bar is empty. The Gang is across the street, arguing with two police officers. The Korean restaurant's awning is singed. Frank is explaining, with the absolute confidence of a man who has talked his way out of worse, that the fire was "a misunderstanding about Korean barbeque."
Nobody is arrested. This surprises Griffin — A-tier should mean arrests — until he sees Frank hand something to one of the officers. Not cash, not obviously. A handshake. The kind that transfers something small and rectangular.
Frank knows cops. Of course Frank knows cops. The show never explained how the Gang avoided prison for seventeen seasons, and the answer is standing right there with a badge and a handshake.
[ACHIEVEMENT UNLOCKED: "I MENTIONED IT" (BRONZE) — +2% SARCASM TIMING]
Sarcasm Timing: +16%. The system awards him his sixth bronze for predicting an A-tier disaster that nearly set a restaurant on fire. Griffin stands in the doorway of Paddy's Pub and reads the achievement notification and does not feel achieved.
---
Paddy's Pub — 11:30 PM
The bar is closed. Griffin is alone — always alone at closing, always the last one out, the person who locks up because nobody else remembers that locks exist.
He sits at the end of the bar. Not Frank's end — the other end, the quiet end, the end where the light doesn't reach and the jukebox hum fades to nothing. The HUD is in passive mode. The Complicity Meter reads 14%. The ratings are dark because nobody's scheming.
He pulls the napkin tally from under the register. Unfolds it.
Seven warnings. Seven dismissals. Seven confirmations. Two from this week alone, both Frank-enhanced, both rated higher than anything in Season 1 by a margin that makes the pre-Frank era feel like a practice round.
The insurance scheme cost nothing — claim denied, no prosecution. The jihad scheme cost an awning and whatever Frank slipped that cop. Frank's money makes the disasters bigger AND makes the consequences smaller. He's not just a modifier — he's an insurance policy for the people who should be uninsurable.
Griffin adds two tally marks. Folds the napkin. Puts it back.
The legal pad under his mattress has a page that says BOOKIE, and under it, a single note: Find the bar where everybody knows Paddy's reputation.
He knows the bar. He's known since November — a place called McKinney's, on Passyunk, six blocks south, where the regulars are the kind of South Philly lifers who've been watching Paddy's Pub implode for years and have opinions about it the way sports fans have opinions about teams: informed, passionate, entertained, and deeply invested in the outcome.
McKinney's has a book. Not the official kind — the kind that operates in the back, where a man named Tommy takes action on anything locals will bet on: Eagles games, neighborhood feuds, city council elections, and — Griffin has heard from two separate delivery drivers — the weekly probability that Paddy's Pub does something newsworthy.
Paddy's Pub: the bar so predictably catastrophic that a bookie takes odds on it.
The math is simple. Griffin has a system that rates disasters before they happen. Tommy has a book that pays out on disasters after they happen. The gap between "before" and "after" is where profit lives.
Griffin locks the register. Wipes the bar. Hangs his apron on the hook by the office door. Checks the lock. Checks it again.
He walks out into January. The cold is absolute — the kind of Philadelphia winter cold that doesn't negotiate, doesn't build gradually, just arrives fully formed and stays. His breath clouds in the streetlight. The Korean restaurant next door has a new awning being installed by a man on a ladder who's cursing in Korean at the cold.
Tomorrow I find Tommy. Tomorrow I walk into McKinney's with cash and predictions and start turning the CPS into something more than a trophy case for being right.
The flip phone buzzes in his pocket. Not Mike — Mike stopped texting in November. A number he doesn't recognize.
He opens it. A text: "its the coffee shop girl. charlie gave me your number from 'the bartender guys phone.' he broke into paddys office to get it. sorry. wanted to say thanks for tuesday. — W"
Griffin stares at the text. Reads it twice. The Waitress — texting from a number Charlie stole from Griffin's phone, which means Charlie broke into the office, found the phone, copied the number, and gave it to the woman he's obsessed with as some kind of deranged gesture that accidentally resulted in a genuine human connection.
Charlie Kelly, accidental matchmaker. The show never covered this.
He types back: "no worries. thanks for the coffee. see you tuesday."
Pockets the phone. Keeps walking. McKinney's is six blocks south and tomorrow is Wednesday and the plan starts now.
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes.
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!