Chapter 12: The One with the Balloon Dog
The Wednesday before Thanksgiving had that particular quality of a day that was technically a regular day but had already given up on being one.
The city outside was moving with a slightly different energy — more purposeful in some directions, more distracted in others, everyone either going somewhere or thinking about going somewhere, the holiday pulling at the edges of everything.
Central Perk was fuller than usual by late afternoon, and then, one by one, with the timing of people who had not coordinated this and were mildly surprised to find themselves doing it, the group reassembled.
Rachel came in first, still in her work apron, sitting down on the couch with the expression of someone who had received news and was still arranging it.
"My parents are going to Florida," she said, to whoever was listening. "Apparently my mom and Mrs. Geller decided they needed a trip, and now the plan is that they're all going together, and the Long Island dinner is — not happening."
"When did this get decided?" Ethan asked.
"Apparently several weeks ago," Rachel said. "My mother mentioned it in a phone call I thought was about something else." She picked up someone's abandoned coffee. "So. I'm here."
Joey arrived ten minutes later with the energy of a man who had experienced something and needed to report it.
He sat down. He looked at the table. He looked at the group.
"I met a woman on the subway," he said.
"Okay," Chandler said.
"Beautiful. Smart. Great energy. We talked the whole ride from 42nd to 86th. She laughed at everything I said. I was on." He paused. "And then we got to 86th, and she looked up at the platform, and there was one of those public health posters."
A beat.
"The flu shot one?" Ethan said.
"The flu shot one," Joey confirmed.
The group processed this. The poster campaign — which Joey had booked through his agent in what had seemed like a straightforward commercial job — had turned out to feature him looking directly into the camera above text that, taken without full context, could be read as suggesting that Joey Tribbiani personally was a vector for communicable illness.
"She saw it," Joey said. "She looked at it, she looked at me, she looked at it again." He made a small gesture that communicated the rest. "She got off at 86th."
"Joey," Phoebe said, with genuine sympathy.
"And then," Joey said, with the expression of a man who had more, "I got to Queens. And my whole family had seen it. My mom, my sisters, my Aunt Gina — all of them, standing in the kitchen, very concerned about my health." He sat back. "I tried to explain that it was a commercial. They wanted to know why, if I was healthy, they would put my face on a disease poster." He looked at Ethan. "I didn't have a great answer for that."
"The honest answer," Ethan said, "is that your face is extremely trustworthy, and public health campaigns need trustworthy faces."
Joey considered this. "That's actually pretty good."
"It's true," Ethan said. "It's a compliment with an unfortunate execution."
"I'm still not going back to Queens tonight," Joey said.
Phoebe came in from the cold looking slightly philosophical, which was her baseline but was more pronounced than usual. She sat down, arranged her coat, and said: "My grandmother has a boyfriend."
"That's nice," Monica said.
"It is nice," Phoebe agreed. "His name is Bernard. He brings her flowers on Tuesdays. She's very happy." She paused. "I didn't want to be in the way of that, so." She made a small gesture indicating that she was here instead.
Ross arrived last, came through the door with his coat still buttoned and sat down without taking it off, which meant the Carol and Susan dinner hadn't gone as well as hoped.
"I lasted an hour and forty minutes," he said.
"Before what?" Chandler asked.
"Before it became clear that I was the third wheel at my own ex-wife's Thanksgiving," Ross said. "They were very kind about it. That almost made it worse."
He finally unbuttoned his coat. The table gave this the respectful silence it deserved.
Everyone looked at Ethan.
"Julia started filming," he said. "New project. She left this morning."
"Where?" Rachel asked.
"Vancouver," Ethan said. "Apparently the location worked better for the production schedule." He said this with the equanimity of a man who had known the timeline going in and had still found the morning slightly quieter than expected.
"So," Monica said, looking around the table at all of them — Rachel without her Long Island dinner, Joey exiled from Queens by a flu poster, Phoebe navigating around her grandmother's happiness, Ross returned early from Carol's, Ethan without Julia, Chandler who had never had a plan to abandon in the first place.
"So," Ethan agreed.
Monica sat up slightly with the particular posture she assumed when she had decided something. "My apartment. Tomorrow. All of us. Proper Thanksgiving."
"Monica," Rachel said, "that's a whole—"
"I want to," Monica said simply. And when Monica said she wanted to cook, that was the end of the structural argument. What followed was logistics.
"What does everyone want?" Monica had already produced a notepad from somewhere, because of course she had.
The requests came in:
Ross: the sweet potato thing their mother made, with the marshmallows on top, even though it was objectively a dessert masquerading as a side dish.
Phoebe: her grandmother's mashed potato recipe, which involved peas and caramelized onions and which Monica received with the expression of someone being asked to do something that violated her instincts but was willing to consider.
Joey: something called Tater Wine, which he explained was a Tribbiani family tradition involving turkey drippings, cranberry sauce, and mashed potato with a specific wine component, and which he freely admitted he had never seen prepared anywhere else in the world.
Rachel: green bean casserole, the exact version from the Campbell's soup can label, which she had been eating since childhood and was not apologetic about.
Chandler: nothing.
Monica looked at him.
"Tomato soup," Chandler said. "Grilled cheese. The onion crackers from the good brand." He said this with the tone of a man who had made his peace with something a long time ago and was not revisiting it.
Monica looked at him for a moment longer. "Okay," she said, and wrote it down without argument, which was, for Monica, a significant act of love.
"Okay but why," Phoebe said, as Monica went to start the prep list.
"Why what?" Chandler said.
"The soup and sandwich situation," Phoebe said. "On Thanksgiving specifically. You celebrate other holidays."
"I tolerate other holidays," Chandler said. "Thanksgiving is different."
Ethan and Monica both looked up at exactly the same moment, caught each other's eyes, and looked back down.
"What?" Chandler said.
"Nothing," Ethan said.
"You both made a face."
"We know the story," Monica said. "We've heard the story. We love you. We don't need to put you through telling it again."
Chandler looked between them. "It's not that bad a story."
"It's a sad story," Ethan said. "About a nine-year-old."
"I was very resilient," Chandler said.
"You were nine," Ethan said.
Chandler opened his mouth, considered the available counterarguments, and closed it again.
"We'll get you the good brand of onion crackers," Monica said. "The ones you actually like."
Chandler looked at the table for a moment. "Thank you," he said, quietly enough that it meant something.
Ross arrived the next morning carrying a bottle of wine and the expression of a man who had been given a task — bring the wine, Ross, that's all you have to do — and was concentrating very hard on having done it correctly.
He set the bottle on the counter, looked at Monica working in the kitchen, and said: "It smells like Mom in here."
Monica turned around with a wooden spoon and the expression of a woman who had been cooking for three hours and was not in the mood for a complicated emotional comparison.
"I am not Mom," she said.
"No, I know, I just meant—"
"Ross."
"The kitchen has a — there's a warmth—"
"Ross, I love you, but if you compare me to Mom one more time while I'm trying to time four separate dishes, I am going to hand you a task."
Ross straightened slightly. "What task?"
"The task will be proportional to the comparison," Monica said. "Do not test this."
Ross looked at Ethan, who was leaning against the counter with his coffee and making no move to intervene.
"You're not going to help?" Ross said.
"I've had this conversation," Ethan said. "I know where it goes. The correct move is to accept the task."
Ross accepted the task, which turned out to be peeling potatoes, which was perhaps not the worst outcome available.
Joey arrived twenty minutes later, looked at the spread on the counter, and zeroed in on Monica immediately.
"The Tater Wine," he said. "I'm not seeing it."
"I'm making it," Monica said. "I looked it up. Your mother's version isn't findable because it doesn't exist outside your family, so I'm extrapolating."
Joey looked slightly alarmed. "You can't extrapolate Tater Wine. It's a sacred text."
"Joey, I will make you something in the spirit of what you described, and it will be good, and you will eat it."
Joey thought about this. "Will it be lumpy?"
"The mashed potato component will be appropriately textured, yes."
"Okay," Joey said, with the careful trust of a man handing something over.
Phoebe arrived and went immediately to the mashed potato situation, which she approached with the specific intentions that Monica had already been briefed on and was bracing for.
"Phoebe," Monica said, without turning around.
"I'm just going to add—"
"Phoebe."
"The peas are already—"
"Phoebe." Monica turned. "I am making three versions of mashed potatoes today. Three. Because I love all of you. You are getting your peas and onions. Ross is getting the lumpy version. Joey is getting the Tater Wine situation. These are three separate bowls. Nobody touches anyone else's bowl."
Phoebe beamed. "That's the most organized thing I've ever heard."
"Thank you," Monica said. "It's what I do."
By early afternoon, the apartment smelled exactly like Thanksgiving is supposed to smell, which is a combination of things that shouldn't necessarily work together but do — roasting turkey, something sweet from the oven, the particular warm-herb smell of stuffing, coffee still going from the morning.
Everyone had migrated to various positions around the apartment. Rachel was on the couch with the parade on TV, which she was watching with the slightly unfocused attention of someone who was thinking about something else and letting the parade be background. Chandler was in the armchair with a book. Phoebe was humming something at the kitchen table. Ross had been promoted from potato-peeling to wine-pouring and was taking the promotion seriously.
Ethan went to the window and looked out at the street.
"Huh," he said.
"What?" Rachel said, from the couch.
"The parade," Ethan said. "Something's happening with one of the balloons."
This got more attention than most statements would have.
The Macy's parade route was a few blocks over, not directly visible from Monica's window but close enough that the tops of the larger balloons were occasionally trackable above the building line. Right now, something was moving wrong — a large shape, cartoon-dog-shaped, drifting with a kind of unhurried wrongness that suggested it had become decoupled from the people responsible for it.
"It's the balloon," Ethan said. "The dog. It's going."
"Going where?" Joey said, appearing from the kitchen.
"Away," Ethan said. "Generally upward and in the direction of the park."
There was approximately half a second of group decision-making, which resolved instantly and unanimously.
"Roof," Monica said, already untying her apron.
"What about the turkey?" Ross said.
"It has seventeen minutes," Monica said, with the precision of a woman who always knew exactly where she was in a cooking timeline. "Roof."
They went to the roof.
The balloon was, in fact, a large inflatable dog of the cartoon variety, and it was in the process of making its way over the western edge of the park in a manner that suggested the handlers had done what they could and the balloon had decided otherwise. It was genuinely spectacular — the scale of it, the absurdity of it, the way it caught the November light.
"It's beautiful," Phoebe said.
"It's enormous," Joey said.
"Someone's having a very bad day," Chandler said, with the sympathetic expression of someone who had also had bad days.
"A lot of someones," Ethan said.
They watched until the balloon had moved far enough that it was more suggestion than shape, and then Monica said "seventeen minutes" and they went back downstairs.
The door, as it turned out, was locked.
This was discovered by Rachel, who had been first back and had tried the handle with the expectant confidence of someone who doesn't anticipate finding it locked, and then stood there with the expression of someone recalibrating.
"Monica," Rachel said.
"I have the keys," Monica said, reaching into her apron pocket.
"The apron you took off," Chandler said. "And left inside."
Monica's hand stilled in her apron pocket. Then she looked at the pocket. Then she looked at the door.
"The oven," she said.
"Is on," Ross confirmed.
"With a turkey in it," Joey said.
"That has approximately—" Monica checked the watch on her wrist. "Twelve minutes."
Everyone looked at Ethan.
Ethan reached into his jacket pocket and produced the keys, which he had picked up from the hook by the door on the way out because he had a standing habit of never leaving a room without knowing who had the keys, a habit developed over years of being the person in the group who thought about these things.
He held them up.
"Hi," he said.
Monica covered her face briefly with both hands. Then she pointed at him. "Not a word."
"I wasn't going to say anything."
"You were going to say something."
"I was going to say you're welcome," Ethan said, and unlocked the door.
The turkey came out with four minutes to spare and was, Monica declared with professional satisfaction, exactly right. The three varieties of mashed potatoes were arranged in separate bowls with small labels — Ross's, Phoebe's, Joey's — which Monica had written in her precise handwriting, and which were the kind of detail that made the whole thing feel intentional rather than improvised.
Chandler's tomato soup and grilled cheese were already plated at his spot, with the good onion crackers beside them, the packaging still on the table so he could confirm the brand.
They sat down.
The table had the particular quality of a Thanksgiving that hadn't been planned three months in advance — slightly mismatched dishes, an improvised centerpiece that Phoebe had assembled from things she'd found in Monica's kitchen, candles that were actually birthday candles because the regular candles were being saved for something. It looked like people lived here, which was the best possible thing a table could look like.
Chandler picked up his glass of water, looked around at all of them, and said: "Okay. Toast."
Everyone picked up their glasses.
"This is not the Thanksgiving anyone planned," Chandler said. "Joey's family thinks he's contagious. Phoebe's grandmother is in love. Ross came home early from an uncomfortable dinner. Rachel's parents are in Florida, presumably doing things I don't want to think about. Julia's in Vancouver. And I — I was planning to spend the day alone, which I will admit sounded better in theory."
He paused.
"So this is a Thanksgiving made entirely of other plans not working out," he said. "And it is — genuinely, and I mean this — one of the better ones I can remember. Which is probably because it has nothing to do with 1977, but also because—" He looked around the table. "I don't know. It's this. You're all very difficult people and I'm very glad you're here."
A beat.
"That's the nicest thing you've ever said," Rachel said.
"Don't get used to it," Chandler said.
"And here's to a miserable Christmas," Joey added.
"To a miserable Christmas," everyone said, and raised their glasses, and drank.
After dinner, they stayed at the table the way you stay at tables after good meals — the food mostly gone, the wine mostly gone, nobody moving with any particular intention, the conversation going wherever it went.
At some point, Ross said: "This is better than Carol's."
"Ross," Monica said.
"I mean — they were very welcoming. Susan made a good pie. I just—" He looked at the table. "This is where I'm supposed to be. Right?"
"Right," Ethan said.
"Yeah," Joey said.
Rachel nodded without saying anything, which was the right call.
Phoebe reached over and squeezed Ross's hand once, briefly, the way she did when words weren't the point.
Outside, the city was doing its Thanksgiving-evening thing — quieter than usual, the streets thinned out, the particular ambient hum of New York receded to something almost manageable. Inside Monica's apartment, the candles were burning down — birthday candles, four inches at most, doing their best — and the table was the comfortable wreckage of a meal that had been eaten properly.
Ethan looked around at all of them.
The plans that hadn't worked out. The dinner that had been improvised from the pieces. The balloon dog, floating somewhere over the park, free of its handlers, going wherever the wind took it.
Not bad, he thought. Not bad at all.
Next: Joey gets a callback from Days of Our Lives. The flu poster situation has further consequences. Ross thinks about Rachel. Chandler wonders about the onion crackers being better here than at home, and what that means.
[Milestone: 500 Power Stones = +1 Chapter]
[Milestone: 10 Reviews = +1 Chapter]
Enjoyed this chapter? Leave a review.
20+advanced chapters on P1treon Soulforger